Review
Elliott
Song In the Air

Revelation (2003) Shane

Elliott – Song In the Air cover artwork
Elliott – Song In the Air — Revelation, 2003

It's always sad to see a pioneer go. Especially when it feels like they have reached the peek of their game. This was the case for Elliott. Since their birth back in 1995, Elliott has cemented themselves as a trailblazer in the "emo" game. With every release, they set new standards on how the game should be played. Your first listen with this release, you might feel as if they have quit the game, when in fact, they are once again just bending the rules.

With half of Elliott gone, mainly the lead songwriter, most were found uncertain as to how they could recruit new members and still be Elliott. Fortunately, newcomer Benny Clark breathed new life into them and helped contribute to their best release yet. Strings, more guitar delay than you can shake a stick at, e-bow coming out the ying-yang. This doesn't sound like the same Elliott we spent those summer nights 3 years ago listening to.

Benny's guitar work fits seemlessly in with Chris Higdon's vocals. Although the "rock" is a bit more toned down on this record, throughout the record, it seems that noone told drummer Kevin Ratterman. He holds one of the most solid backbeats in the independent music scene today, while playing with more heart and soul than anyone out there. He throws his body into each crash, as if it were his last. You can only imagine how often they had to tell him to tone it down.

Although I am a huge fan of Chris' vocals, the instrumental track, "Drag Like Pull," is far and away the big winner on this record. Showing the dynamic capabilities of this band, they sway back and forth from a mezzo-piano to a full out fortissimo. You can just imagine Kevin's hair swaying back and forth into his eyes and he pounds out the intricate beats while Benny and Chris sing back and forth to each other using only their guitars.

Sure, some will say "It's no False Catherdrals." Well I can tell you that it's not supposed to be. Elliott gave it their all in this release and it shows. They have brought the intensity they had in their earlier days and applied it to a more mature song writing process. With that method, they completed my favorite Elliott record. Don't be put off by anything you have heard. Please do yourself a favor and look into this record.

8.7 / 10Shane • February 29, 2004

Elliott – Song In the Air cover artwork
Elliott – Song In the Air — Revelation, 2003

Related features

Top 5 Elliott Smith Songs That'll Choke You Up

Music / The Set List • March 7, 2011

Related news

The Music of Heatmiser

Posted in Records on August 17, 2023

Team Dresch, Built To Spill (and Elliott Smith)

Posted in Tours on December 19, 2021

More Elliott reviews

Elliott

Photorecording
Revelation (2005)

This is not a re-release. Photorecording is Elliott's last testament. Allow me to regress a few years. I had always dismissed them as overrated. US Songs was okay, but it just seemed like it was missing that little extra something. When False Cathedrals came out, I gave them another chance; it was their statement, an almost perfect 10 in my … Read more

Elliott

False Cathedrals
Revelation (2000)

There are those records out there where people can point to them as a turning point in their musical taste or a shift in their musical aesthetic and say that the record really changed how they viewed entire swathes of music or entire genres, and I will never forget the day that I bought False Cathedrals from Elliott in part … Read more