Review / 200 Words Or Less
Basalt Fingers
Basalt Fingers

Three Lobed (2007) — Campbell

Basalt Fingers – Basalt Fingers cover artwork
Basalt Fingers – Basalt Fingers — Three Lobed, 2007

This album definitely puts the "post" back in post-rock. The album consists of only two tracks, each clocking in over twenty minutes. The result is a pretty minimal endeavor, with lots of feedback and ominous sound effects. Obviously, bands like Godspeed! You Black Emperor immediately come to mind, but even that band has more structure than Basalt Fingers.

Throughout the album, I found myself asking, "Am I still listening to this?" The entirety of the album is almost nothing more than a low drone with slightly varying pitches. This may cross the point of not being music after a while, just disconnected noises that you don't ordinarily hear. The second track seems to have a little more going on at any given point, but still rarely resembles a recognizable musical progression.

I'm cautious to say I hate this album, because conceptually it may have some validity. But I'm so used to song structure of any kind, no matter how disjointed it might be, that I can't see myself wanting to ever put this on again. Even in a drugged-out stupor I still don't think you would be able to grasp this one.

2.0 / 10 — Campbell • March 6, 2008

Basalt Fingers – Basalt Fingers cover artwork
Basalt Fingers – Basalt Fingers — Three Lobed, 2007

Recently-posted album reviews

Sweeping Promises

You Say I Romanticize
Sub Pop (2026)

What strikes me foremost about this record are the vocals. As the father of a 13 y.o. daughter I feel qualified to say that this person could be a pop singer. I mean I don’t really know what it takes to be one, although I’m sure that it’s more than a voice good enough to win a game show, I’ve … Read more

Moonraker

Me and the Bells
Punkerton Records (2026)

I have probably talked about this before, I knew of Moonraker through split EPs and things like that, but they didn't fully pop into my consciousness until The Forest. Me and the Bells, four years later, is their follow-up full-length and it continues the trajectory from that record while still capturing its own distinct vibe. Musically the band is heavily … Read more

Dreamwell

Hymns for the Denial of God
Prosthetic (2026)

Some records make their intentions obvious from the very beginning. They use the same structure that countless bands have for decades: verse, chorus, breakdown, payoff, and the blunt force of explaining what you are supposed to feel. Hymns for the Denial of God does something much more complex. It’s a series of difficult questions no one wants to answer, proposed … Read more