Review
Orange Island
Orange Island

Triple Crown (2003) Michael

Orange Island – Orange Island cover artwork
Orange Island – Orange Island — Triple Crown, 2003

Orange Island are one of those bands who have had the unfortunate luck of being horribly mislabeled as emo. A more accurate description of their sound would be calling them an abrasive yet matured indie-rock band with an awareness of a pop-filled past. With the help of two previous releases, an EP and full-length with Iodine Records, Orange Island have developed for themselves a sound all to their own.

The album's opening track initially opens in a somber mood with soft acoustic guitars and eased drumming, but things quickly make a transition into a frenzy of crisp guitar work and upbeat vocal melodies. "Oh! How Clintonian of Me" continues on in similar fashion filled with fast-paced pop-influenced punk that could have easily landed its place on a Bad Religion album. As the album unveils itself, we are show the diversity in the musicianship. Orange Island fail to be pigeonholed as a one-trick act. While indie-rock bands Hum and Samiam helped paved the way for the genre, Orange Island has taken those ideas and infused them with the energy of a sugar-crazed five-year-old. Where as the music contained on the self-titled work may seem very fitting to a pop-punk/emo tag, the lyrical content speaks otherwise. The songs deal with the darker side of everyday life; the subject matter varies from the death of loved ones and suicide to the disappointment of failed relationships and the personal battles of family life and religion. Needless to say this isn't your everyday radio-rock band. But with cuts like "Life as a Series of Addictions" and "Holy Bibles and Stained Glass Hotel Windows", the thought of hearing them between New Found Glory and Thrice on your local radio station doesn't seem all that improbable. The album rounds out with the sincere and honest yet angry and regretful "The Bachelorette, Her Neck and a Drunk as Joe Millionaire" which is the self-confession of the failure to hold onto one's true love.

Orange Island's latest album provides the perfect blueprint for up-and-coming bands to follow. This is the correct way to distinguish oneself. While their mixing of both influences of past and peers of today may not be 100% genuine, at least it is a sound that they can call their own. If you crave honest and fun indie/pop or rock-n-roll music, this will be a great addition to your collection.

7.0 / 10Michael • March 12, 2004

Orange Island – Orange Island cover artwork
Orange Island – Orange Island — Triple Crown, 2003

Related news

Orange Island's One Night Stay back in print

Posted in Records on July 10, 2022

Recently-posted album reviews

Sahan Jayasuriya

Don’t Say Please: The Oral History of Die Kreuzen
Feral House (2026)

For those of us who spent the mid-to-late 1980s navigating basement community halls, churches, and loveable, armpit-smelling dive bars, the name Die Kreuzen was a permanent fixture on the punk rock radar. They were the sound of the Midwest underground --too fast for the goths to do their spooky Bela Lugosi "shoo the bats away" interpretive dance, too technical for … Read more

Sewer Urchin

Global Urination
Independent (2025)

There’s a fine line between crossover thrash that feels dangerous and crossover thrash that just feels like a party. Global Urination doesn’t bother choosing because it does both loudly and without apology. St. Louis’ Sewer Urchin have been grinding since 2019, and on their latest full length they double down on everything that makes the genre work. They give us … Read more

Ingested

Denigration
Metal Blade (2026)

For a band that built its name on sheer brutality, Ingested have spent the last several years refining what that brutality actually means. With their newest release, Denigration, the band finds that continuing evolution. They’re still punishing, still precise, but noticeably more controlled and deliberate in how it all lands. From the outset, the record makes its intentions clear. “Dragged … Read more