Feature / Music
2011: A Year In Review

January 2, 2012

2011: A Year In Review
2011: A Year In Review

The five most painful musical moments of 2011

The five most painful musical moments of 2011

5

Dubstep

There's nothing inherently wrong with dubstep. It's an interesting genre and, executed well, it's actually pretty enjoyable. The problem is, guys, you've all been hemorrhaging crappy dime-a-dozen tracks in the genre without any care to the composition. Sure, a few of you are really taking the effort to make this work. We appreciate it. But for everyone else: please stop writing dubstep music solely to remain relevant to the modern pop music scene. If you're going to do it, do it well, and then we won't all be collectively sick of hearing it.

4

"Party Rock Anthem"

Look, LMFAO. We need to have a chat. No one here wants to listen to obnoxious synth lines and watch you do the Melbourne shuffle over a thinly veiled 28 Days Later parody. Even less do we want to hear the rest of your chaff-filled album. And honestly, it's not just because your music is terrible; it's because you'd have a hard time beating a cardboard cutout of Mick Jagger in terms of stage presence. Quite honestly, there is nothing redeeming about experiencing your band in any way, unless you count internal bleeding as a positive. Honestly, we're getting pretty close to considering it.

3

Adrenaline Mob

You're breaking our hearts, Portnoy. You're a wonderful, talented musician. We want to see you succeed. You had some issues with Dream Theater? That's fine, buddy. Dust it off and pick yourself up again. You're still a VIP in the progressive world. You know what, we're even fine if you want to record straight-up hard rock or heavy metal. Whatever floats your boat. Just, please, once you have an all-star lineup behind you and the chance to record the album of a lifetime, make sure you take a moment, evaluate what you have, and do it well. Don't churn out a tripe album like your debut EP. You have a chance to do something amazing with these musicians; please take the time to do your first full-length album well.

2

Lulu

Okay, we get it. You're hipper and more cultured than the rest of us, Metallica. Look at you, palling up with Lou Reed and producing an album only a masochist could enjoy. If that makes you happy, by all means, please do so. But don't cower behind the 'avant-garde' label. Don't go into interviews with tears in your eyes about how beautiful of an album it is. Just admit that it's music you wanted to make regardless of how good it actually is, and we'll be happy. It's not the fact that you made such a terrible album that bothers us. It's the fact that you willfully ignore all of the critical feedback to it that makes us believe you are stuck in your own delusional fantasyland. We were fine with Death Magnetic--at least that was a step back in the right direction. But for the love of god, if you don't release something spectacular after Lulu, we're done.

1

"Friday"

You know what? There are no excuses for this one. We all weep for Rebecca Black's no doubt troubled future, dealing with perpetual social alienation from her peers as she gets older.

Words: Matthew Sarah

Skip to page View as a single page

— words by the SPB team • January 2, 2012

2011: A Year In Review
2011: A Year In Review

Pages in this feature

  1. Opening page
  2. The top seven albums we were promised (and didn't get) in 2011
  3. The top five albums from classic rock musicians who have no business releasing more music in 2011
  4. Five awesome 2011 reissues
  5. Ten great (legally) free albums from 2011
  6. Top 5 releases of 2011 that don't really count
  7. The top EPs released in 2011
  8. The top five debut releases of 2011
  9. The top five honourable mentions of 2011
  10. The top five London live shows of 2011
  11. The 20 best hip-hop records of 2011
  12. The top ten progressive albums of 2011
  13. The top five Fest sets we caught and missed in 2011
  14. The top record labels of 2011
  15. The top ten post-rock albums of 2011
  16. Five 2011 records I've slept on so far
  17. Top 10 Splits & Collaborations of 2011
  18. Top 10 Cassettes Releases of 2011
  19. Top 10 Musical Obsessions from 2011
  20. The five most painful musical moments of 2011

Related features

Commerce or Amusement? #1

Regular Columns / Commerce or Amusement? • June 9, 2026

Are You In The Music Business? Or Just Involved In Music? Interview Series #1 Featuring Jordan Stamm of Drunk Dial Records CC: Hello Jordan! Could you start off by telling the readers a little bit about yourself and Drunk Dial Records? Do you recall how you and I met? JS: … Read more

J Mau & The Kiss Off

ASL interpreter

Interviews / Don't Quit Your Day Job • June 8, 2026

There are a lot of misconceptions about the life of a musician. Most musicians have day jobs – and not just to pay the bills. Jobs provide new challenges, personal fulfillment and, yes, some rent or gas money. How an artist spends their time by day will influence the creative … Read more

Crash Outfit

One Question Interviews • June 5, 2026

Paul Warner (Crash Outfit) SPB: How much space in your home is dedicated to music (media or instruments)? Warner: I would say it equals the exact dimensions of a well-fed woolly mammoth. Read more

General Chaos

One Question Interviews • June 3, 2026

Constantin (General Chaos) SPB: What is a lesson you learned from the making-of your first album that directly influenced how you approached album #2? Constantin: I think when we came into studio the second time, we already had an idea of what to expect since we knew the studio and … Read more

Bat Leather

One Question Interviews • June 1, 2026

Cory (Bat Leather) SPB: What is your favorite music-related film or documentary? Cory: It’s a tie between The Color of Noise and Some Kind of Monster. TCON is possibly the greatest snapshot of the ‘90s noise rock scene. Great interviews and amazing footage. SKOM….Love ‘em or hate ‘em, but watching … Read more

More from this section

Demos You Want To Check #3

Music / New Kids On The Block • May 8, 2026

The musical landscape is ever changing. New genres are popping up, new hypes burst out of nowhere and die out and new bands present themselves to the world. How on earth are you expected to keep up, right? Well, it never hurts to help! So here we are, your humble … Read more

Guest List: War On Women

Music / The Set List • April 24, 2026

It feels like a lifetime ago when Mitt Romney referenced a "war on women" during the 2012 presidential cycle. A lot has changed, a lot has stayed the same -- but a new politically-charged band formed in the aftermath of that comment, calling themselves War On Women. Now, roughly 14 … Read more

The New York Dolls: Reflections and Legacy

Music • March 30, 2026

I first discovered the New York Dolls in the mid-to-late 1980s, just as I was beginning to stretch the boundaries of my musical journey. Up until then, my exposure to music had mostly come through my parents, aunts, and uncles. They planted the initial seeds, and those seeds quickly grew, … Read more