Review
Stars of the Lid
And Their Refinement of the Decline

Kranky (2007) Shane

Stars of the Lid – And Their Refinement of the Decline cover artwork
Stars of the Lid – And Their Refinement of the Decline — Kranky, 2007

When it comes to currently running ambient acts, they do not get any more prolific than Stars of the Lid. Having released material since 1995, the duo made up of Brian McBride and Adam Wiltzie have relocated since releasing their last album and absolute masterpiece The Tired Sounds Of... and found themselves living more than 6,000 miles apart. This distance might have put a lull in terms of releasing albums but it surely has not taken away from the quality of their output as And Their Refinement of the Decline reminds us that there is no one who does it better than these two.

While I sit, geographically almost halfway in between members in a coffee shop in Toledo, OH, I am reminded exactly why you shouldn't listen to records like this in places like these. The silences created by Stars of the Lid in between large moving drones molded from strings, horns, guitars, and various other instruments are not meant to be filled with some scruffy faced twenty-something doing John Mayer covers. Instead they are there to ground you and remind you that you are where you are. There are plenty of reminders as well as this album spans two CD's and finds itself lasting over two hours.

On the surface it does seem like not much has changed since The Tired Sounds Of..., but that is certainly not the case. There are more songs as opposed to songs divided into separate movements. Despite the idea of movements becoming further removed, the album does take on a bit more of an orchestral feel with the amount of horns and strings on the album. Songs such as "Apreludes (In C Sharp Major)" and "Hiberner Toujours" demonstrate this the best on the album. The band has continued with some of the romantic song titles found on The Tired Sounds Of with songs like "Even If You're Never Awake (Deuxième)" but found themselves going back to some of their more sarcastic titles as well with "That Finger on Your Temple is the Barrel of My Raygun" and one of the best song titles I have ever heard, "December Hunting for Vegetarian Fuckface" proving that underneath all of that very serious music is a light side to it all.

Over the years the band has found itself with other projects and you can feel the influence on this album from them. "A Meaningful Moment Through a Meaning(Less) Process" sounds as if it were off of McBride's solo album When the Detail Lost It's Freedom while "Humectez La Mouture" displays a sound established best from Wiltzie's work with The Dead Texan. Neither project strayed incredibly far from Stars of the Lid's style but it's nice to see the changes they did have incorporated into Stars of the Lid's newest work.

Overall, I think any prior fan of Stars of the Lid knew that they wouldn't disappoint with a new record. With the newfound resurgence of ambient music lately with artists such as Eluvium, Mountains, and even Growing, this record will be a very nice introduction to one of the long running veterans of the scene. And Their Refinement of the Decline is an instant classic and a reminder that they are surely one of the best duos ever.

9.7 / 10Shane • April 24, 2007

Stars of the Lid – And Their Refinement of the Decline cover artwork
Stars of the Lid – And Their Refinement of the Decline — Kranky, 2007

Recently-posted album reviews

Vial

Hellhound
Trout Hole Records (2026)

I was really into the last Vial record, a quick burst of peppy and pointed brat punk. The early singles off Hellhound lean way more grunge, so I was curious how the band had developed in the past couple of years. And while my very first impressions of "Infected" and "Scorpio Moon" had me thinking of L7 and Nirvana, by … Read more

Mauled

When Your Eyes Are Shut
Silverback Gorilla Records (2026)

Deathcore has spent the last decade mutating into increasingly technical, polished, and theatrical territory. Some bands chase symphonic grandeur. Others lean into hyper-technical brutality. The Indianapolis wrecking crew named Mauled take a different approach on When Your Eyes Are Shut. They drag the genre back toward the raw chaos of its early years. This six track EP feels deliberately rooted … Read more

DMZ

The Lost Studio Sessions-1978
Crypt Records (2026)

The Lost Studio Sessions 1978 finally sets the record straight. This is the raw, ugly power the band’s debut never touched. For years, the DMZ legacy has been misunderstood because of that Sire LP. Look, it was the first record of theirs I ever heard and I still love it—but Flo & Eddie’s production smoothed over everything that made them … Read more