Review
Camera Obscura
Underachievers Please Try Harder

Merge (2004) Steve

Camera Obscura – Underachievers Please Try Harder cover artwork
Camera Obscura – Underachievers Please Try Harder — Merge, 2004

With the state of pop music looking more and more depressing with every year, it is always nice to hear a band whose influences reach a bit deeper than the latest craze. In the case of Glasgow, Scotland's Camera Obscura (not to be confused with the San Diego band of same name), cues are taken as much from the British Invasion as they are from The Field Mice and more contemporary indie-pop gems such as Belle & Sebastian and Saturday Looks Good to Me.

In recent years many bands playing this style of twee-pop have surfaced with mixed results and seemingly incomplete-sounding albums. Thankfully for Camera Obscura, they don't suffer from this same curse, as Underachievers... is solid all the way through and flows quite well from one track to the next. Smooth vocal melodies and excellent transitions are just the tip of the iceberg when discussing this record. Rather than sticking to one specific sub-genre, Camera Obscura incorporate elements of blues, folk, and jazz into their orch-pop niche and make it work like only they can. My favorite track on the record is "Books Written For Girls," a slow piano ballad that produces tear-jerking results. Other standouts include "Teenager," Number One Son," and the song that should be played at every high school dance, "A Sisters Social Agony."

Camera Obscura isn't going to change the face of music with Underachievers Please Try Harder, but they have crafted one of the best pop records of the year so far. If you are looking for a soundtrack to a rainy afternoon or a mild summer day (depending on how you interpret the music), Underachievers Please Try Harder should be it.

8.0 / 10Steve • August 6, 2004

Camera Obscura – Underachievers Please Try Harder cover artwork
Camera Obscura – Underachievers Please Try Harder — Merge, 2004

Recently-posted album reviews

Sweat

Tear it on Down
Vitriol (2026)

Tear It On Down is the third record from Sweat and it picks up where the last two left off. It's aggressive hardcore punk, but with a playful groove or swagger that really makes it feel uplifting, even when the content is not. Case in point: "Surveillance State," which rolls kind of like a call-and-response song, except that lead vocalist … Read more

Latchkey Kids

Years Of Summers
Pathetic Pinky Party (2026)

Growing up is rarely cinematic in real time but when you look back, it can feel mythic. On Year Of Summers, New Jersey’s Latchkey Kids frame heartbreak, identity, and grief through something closer to epic storytelling than simple emo confession. It’s a record that understands the drama of youth without romanticizing it. Frontman Hanny Ramadan positions the album as a … Read more

Mental Gymnast

Mental Gymnast
Say-10 (2026)

Recipe: Mental Gymnast Self-Titled Creator: Mental Gymnast Cookbook: Say-10 Recipes Copyright: 2/27/26 Ingredients: 1 Very Ripe Adam Gecking on Vocals 1 Stick Unsalted Erica Clayton on Bass 2 Slices Scotty Sandwich (1 Slice Guitar, 1 Slice Drums) 1 Dash Chris Ruckus on Synths Directions: *Preheat the recording studio to 65 degrees. Add all of the ingredients together in “One Big … Read more