Review
Florence and the Machine
Lungs

Island (2009) Matt

Florence and the Machine – Lungs cover artwork
Florence and the Machine – Lungs — Island, 2009

In a U.K. pop scene increasingly dominated by uncertain female electro-pop princesses or paltry imitations of Rihanna or Beyonce, it's refreshing and exciting to see the dominance of a genuinely interesting and invigorating talent. Twenty-three year old Florence Welch and her four accomplices - The Machine - present us a gift wrapped collection of thirteen buoyant, ethereal and enormous songs.

Production is large and swelling, with harps, keys, strings and choirs liberally applied. Unlike Phil Spector and his overly ubiquitous wall of sound, however, these arrangements never feel Pro Tooled into place, instead situating themselves succinctly around Welch's absolutely awe-inspiring vocals. Opener "Dog Days are Over" gives us a sample from the veritable smorgasbord that Lungs offers up: "El Condor Pasa"-era Simon & Garfunkel strings, ghostly choirs, darkly colored lyrics and those throaty, shouty, angelic lead vocals. Followed straight up by single "Rabbit Heart (Raise it Up)," we're drawn in completely, with a chorus that will float innocently around your eardrums for weeks.

"Kiss With a Fist" is a White Stripes song, offering a lyrical tale of domestic violence told controversially: "A kick in the teeth is good for some / a kiss with a fist is better than none." Derivative drum/guitar combos aside, this upbeat blues rock tune helps keep the album varied, and avoids stepping into generic TV advert muzak by including an over-driven guitar solo that could be a lo-fi garage punk band, spluttering through notes like a buzzsaw.

Keeping things interesting, the next track is the wonderfully creepy "Girl With One Eye," featuring a fantastic guitar sound accompanying the word 'cut' in "I took a knife and cut out her eye." These little details keep the record edgy, before it gradually climaxes into a vocal-drenched funeral dirge wailfest.

"Cosmic Love" is another standout, harps ascending and descending throughout with a sense of space and scale that match the track's name. The latter half of the record becomes more introspective and dreamy, until we close up with "Blinding" and, finally, a cover of Candi Staton's "You've Got The Love," which somehow works, although feels a little misplaced after the epic pop of the previous half hour.

What's to dislike? Not every jaded hardcore fan will be able to bring themselves to listen to a red-haired British pop star penning sultry and genre-spanning baroque rock/pop, but for everyone else, there's a lot to be gained. Give this the time it deserves and you'll be rewarded.

9.0 / 10Matt • January 4, 2010

Florence and the Machine – Lungs cover artwork
Florence and the Machine – Lungs — Island, 2009

Related news

Recently-posted album reviews

Alien Nosejob

How A Mosquito Operates
Anti Fade, Iron Lung (2026)

The one-man band of Alien Nosejob continues to crank out short, angry hardcore in quick bursts. I've lost count of how many records Jake Robertson has now released under the name. I'll just say that while the first couple took some direction changes, the project seems to have found its footing in 1980s-influenced hardcore. With 17 songs in 24 minutes, … Read more

Cancer Bats

Give Me Dirt
Marshall Amplification PLC, New Damage records (2026)

ALBUM HIGHLIGHTS – “Bright Eyes of Gold”, “Give Me Dirt”, “Long Tooth”, “Fools Like You” Almost exactly two years ago, on 8th August 2024, Cancer Bats played Conne Island in Leipzig – a choice they would live to regret. Unbeknownst to them at the time, the centre had slowly become renowned for its radical politics and, more recently, the ban … Read more

Tyler Sonnichsen

The Dead Milkmen
J-Card Press (2026)

When I saw The Dead Milkmen at Toronto’s Diamond Club back in the late 1980s, the floor was a volatile, beautiful mess of colliding subcultures. It was like different species of house flies bumping into one another, wondering what the hell you were doing in the mason jar. You had suburban high school pocket-pen-protector pencil-neck nubile nerds, college radio snobs … Read more