Review
Flotilla
Disaster Poetry

Independent (2006) — Peanut

Flotilla – Disaster Poetry cover artwork
Flotilla – Disaster Poetry — Independent, 2006

Taste is a strange thing. You start to form an opinion on something from the first contact with it. Take Flotilla for example - a four piece indie-rock band that includes a classically trained harpist and, according to their press release, "a noted composer of contemporary concert music." Now to be honest, the first thing flashed into my mind was Charlotte Church - the well known child prodigy that went from Opera to pop in a blaze of mediocrity - and the first parts of my taste was beginning to warn me off.

However, I persevered and found the band's album, Disaster Poetry, to be a somewhat enjoyable and engaging album, if somewhat fitting into the dreaded category of music you would play at a dinner party and could easily sit alongside Dido and other such bands in a CD collection of middle aged women who only buy one or two albums a year, usually in Tesco.

The problem with Disaster Poetry is that it is really unthreatening. The album never really changes gears at all and seems to just drift along at a serene pace. This does not mean that the album lacks passion, far from it in fact, as vocalist and lyricist Veronica Charnley's angelic voice soars throughout. It's just a shame that a voice like this is not really pushed by the band to do more. Charnley has a great voice and it is not pushed nearly as much as it should be.

This album is not really my cup of tea. It's not a bad album but at the same time it's not something I would ever buy on my own accord. It all comes down to taste, and there is certainly a large market for Flotilla and it's a very profitable market as well. It's just I'm not really in that group and don't think I ever will be. However, I do now have another Christmas present for my mum sorted.

5.0 / 10 — Peanut • October 24, 2007

Flotilla – Disaster Poetry cover artwork
Flotilla – Disaster Poetry — Independent, 2006

Recently-posted album reviews

Pete Shelley

Sky Yen
Cold Spring (2026)

I played this on Halloween to spook the trick or treaters. My wife thought it was weird which is probably why I thought it was perfect. It’s foreboding and a bit disorienting, like John Carpenter’s spooky synth scores but less rhythmic and more ambient like Brian Eno’s Discreet Music. It actually pre-dates both as it was recorded in 1974 while … Read more

21 BUM SALUTE

PARTY DOZEN
City Slang (2026)

ALBUM HIGHLIGHTS – “Mad Rooter”, “Full Powers”, “Captain Honk”, “The Stinking Rose”Despite its disarming title, 21 Bum Salute offers not just a delightful sonic din but a strangely convincing take on…wait for it: hunting music. Not the kind of hunting done by rich people in tweed jackets and flat caps, but the urban-jungle kind – set against the menacing backdrop … Read more

The Monsters

Off The Road We go
Voodoo Rhythm (2026)

After 40 years of knuckle-dragging, drooling, drop-kicking drudgery, Switzerland's premier exporter of underground electrifying neck bolts is back. The Monsters return with 12 tracks of raw noise that clearly demonstrate they haven't lost a fraction of their edge to their sharpened fangs—bubbling test tubes, popping corks, and setting off a series of small photopsia explosions of light right behind your … Read more