Review
Idlewild
Warnings / Promises

Parlophone (2005) — Neil F.

Idlewild – Warnings / Promises cover artwork
Idlewild – Warnings / Promises — Parlophone, 2005

In 2002, Bob Fairfoul walked out of Idlewild with a rain of misdirected punches. From that moment, it seemed impossible that the next album would be anything other than either a return to an older, easier sound, or a radical change. When bassist Gavin Fox from Irish band Turn and long-term tour guitarist Allan Stewart were drafted into the new look five-piece, we were still left guessing as to which it would be.

It took until January 2005, when Idlewild embarked on a series of acoustic shows in which they took their back catalogue and several of the new songs, and stripped them down to bare basics, before the answer was given. They played their songs, the same songs they'd been playing for years. Except, this time, they played their songs as they were written. And that is what Warnings / Promises is. An album recorded the way it was written to sound.

On first listen, the changes to the basic Idlewild sound were as obvious as always, yet the difficulty was in deciding why or how it was so. Beyond the odd glimpses of pedal steel guitars, it is hard to see what there is on this album that they haven't come close to doing before. But that's the thing. It's easy to look at Warnings / Promises and wonder what is so new about it, without realizing that Idlewild aren't the same band they were in 2002. They have moved on and started fresh, forgetting everything that got them this far. As opposed to nothing being new, everything is.

As with every release since 100 Broken Windows, not all Idlewild fans will be pleased. In fact, I'm not even sure Warnings / Promises will please fans of The Remote Part. It is slow paced, relying heavily on acoustic guitars, folk influences and country tinges. Even the moments that delve a little more heavily into the old electric guitars and distortion routine, such as "Blame It on Obvious Ways", "The Space Between All Things" and first single "Love Steals Us from Loneliness" seem more subdued, more thought about than bashed out.

But it isn't really in these songs that the true beauty of this album lays. It is in the fact that the whole album is stripped down to the bare bones of good song writing (most notable on songs like "Welcome Home", "El Capitan" and "Not Just Sometimes but Always"). Warnings / Promises offers a refreshing glance at what real music with a rhythm, a melody and a story to it can sound like. It is one of the few albums that doesn't break down this most basic of all formulae. It is without the self-indulgent braggadociosness of contemporaries and without the necessity to pall songs in layer upon layer of overdubbed timbres in which they finally become lost.

This is the real heart of Warnings / Promises - that it is one of those most unusual of albums that relies, not on studio effects and producers, but on good songs in their very most pure of forms.

9.7 / 10 — Neil F. • July 21, 2005

Idlewild – Warnings / Promises cover artwork
Idlewild – Warnings / Promises — Parlophone, 2005

Related features

Idlewild

Interviews

Related news

TMBG tours

Posted in Tours on November 3, 2015

New TMBG

Posted in Bands on September 23, 2015

They Might Be Giants comp in the works

Posted in Records on April 9, 2014

Recently-posted album reviews

David Eugene Edwards

Mercurial Silence
Sargent House (2026)

David Eugene Edwards's 2023 full-length Hyacinth was a significant turn in his musical journey. Americana still defined much of the record's spirit, from the guitar lines and the song structures, but the backbone was forged in electronica. While this shift was sonically significant, it did not alter Edwards's existential and ritualistic interests. In fact it amplified these concepts, imbuing his … Read more

Nagusame

I Want To Leave
White Russian Records (2026)

Nagusame are not reinventing melodic metalcore on I Want To Leave. They wear their influences openly, and anyone familiar with Shai Hulud, Misery Signals, or early-2000s metalcore will hear them almost immediately. What keeps the EP from feeling like simple nostalgia is what Nagusame does with those influences, especially the guitars.The guitars are what stay with me when I Want … Read more

AIH

Self-Titled EP
Independent (2026)

EP HIGHLIGHTS – “McEnroe” & “Ten Speed”Hatching out of COVID boredom between friends down on NYC’s Lower East Side, drummer Doug Stern and vocalist-guitarist Brian Runk casually kickstarted AIH by jamming through some classic rock and early punk covers. It's a preference that’s made abundantly clear via their high-energy live shows and staple sound of sturdy guitar, memorable chant-driven hooks … Read more