Review
Liars
Drum's Not Dead

Mute (2006) Neil

Liars – Drum's Not Dead cover artwork
Liars – Drum's Not Dead — Mute, 2006

Tonight I watched The Blair Witch Project on television for the first time in quite a while. Before you read on, you should know that I may possibly spoil some of the film if you've never seen it before. But really, where the fuck were you in 1999? Anyway, the closing sequence: crazy irritating woman runs around frantically in a desolate dark house in the middle of nowhere before good fortune intervenes and she is struck down, dropping her grainy camera to a dusty floor. This, in turn, made me think of Liars.

Unfortunately Drum's Not Dead is at least seven years too late to be considered as a possible accompany piece to the aforementioned film, and that is a great shame, as the two are now bedfellows in my mind. Not just due to Liars already established interest in witches (see 2004's excellent They Were Wrong So We Drowned), but more simply because of the pervading dark, unsettling mood the album creates through its often gritty production, droning vocals and throbbing sound collages. Most songs seep comfortably into one another, retaining a similar mood, feel and sound reminiscent of early Sonic Youth crossed with mid career Black Dice and the obligatory mention of This Heat and Einstürzende Neubauten.

Continuing with the "album as a singular piece rather than a collection of songs" angle, every track here bar one has either "Mt. Heart Attack" or "Drum" in the title. Certainly, it is the bands most percussion centered work to date and a far cry from their early post-punk incarnation. The one song that stands out, in terms of being different rather than necessarily better is album closer "The Other Side of Mt. Heart Attack." Very much a case of the light at the end of the tunnel; it provides the few hopeful, sunshine graced few minutes on an otherwise morose record. Granted, if I was reaching for one record to take with me to play while I sit and drink heavily in the middle of the woods alone at night I'd still go for Wolf Eyes' superb Dead Hills EP, but Drum's not Dead would not be far behind on my short list.

Much like The Blair Witch Project, Drum's Not Dead will have its fair share of detractors. Having any semblance of being "hip" will do that to you though, and it's hard not to fall short when some people hold you aloft so high. The Blair Witch Project may not be the scariest film ever made [personal note: it isn't] as many claimed at the time, and similarly Liars are not the saviors of noisy art rock, but I still enjoy both all the same.

7.8 / 10Neil • February 14, 2006

Liars – Drum's Not Dead cover artwork
Liars – Drum's Not Dead — Mute, 2006

Related news

Liars Academy covers Leatherface

Posted in MP3s on July 30, 2023

Liars Academy limited reissues

Posted in Records on October 15, 2022

Recently-posted album reviews

Osmium

Osmium
Invada (2025)

Osmium brings together four artistic heavyweights, united not just by a shared experimental ethos, but by a love of bespoke and often self-made instruments. On their debut record, Hildur Guðnadóttir harnesses the unstable feedback of the halldorophone, a cello-like instrument designed by Halldór Úlfarsson. James Ginzburg (emptyset) contributes tamboura-like drones using a monocord of his own design. Sam Slater operates … Read more

Lutheran Heat

Hi Again
Pinata Records (2025)

Lutheran Heat have one of my favorite band names, a distinctly Minnesota tongue-in-cheek nod to local culture and mannerisms. But while I dig the band name, that's not really relevant to the rest of this review. Hi Again is their first record in 9 years, but it continues their garagey indie-punk tones. Expect garage rock guitar tones, slacker indie rock … Read more

Huma Utku

Dracones
Editions Mego (2025)

Huma Utku is an explorer. From her early days under the R.A.N (Roads at Night) moniker, she displayed a deep appreciation for experimental electronic music. From the outset, Utku wove together dark ambient motifs, industrial themes, and post-club abstraction into a minimalist yet holistic vision. Since adopting her own name, that same sonic excavation has continued, with a sharpened focus … Read more