Murder By Death
Bitter Drink, Bitter Moon

Bloodshot (2012) Aaron H

Murder By Death – Bitter Drink, Bitter Moon cover artwork
Murder By Death – Bitter Drink, Bitter Moon — Bloodshot, 2012

Murder by Death are back with their sixth studio album, and it's their moodiest album yet. It's a stark contrast to their last record, Good Morning, Magpie--returning to, while exploring, more layers of atmospheric tones. With each album(excluding Red of Tooth...), I always found myself needing to give them multiple rounds to fully appreciate what I was listening to--Bitter Drink, Bitter Moon is no exception. Bit by bit I'm falling in love with this record. However, it does stumble at the beginning.

One thing Murder by Death have always done right, were their openers. Bitter Drink, Bitter Moon has a hard time taking flight. The opener, "My Hill" could have been a great introduction to the record, but even at just two and a half minutes, it's too long. It's not a bad song by any means. it just happens to be slow and lack any real pay off. Then, it almost feels like the record starts over with "Lost River." The track written by cellist, Sarah Balliet, finds influence from the band's first album, and then leads into the chugging sound of Matt Armstrong's bass on "Straight at the Sun." The two back-to-back give you a better sense of those 1-2-punches Murder by Death have pulled off flawlessly in the past as opposed to "My Hill" followed by "Lost River." The next track, "No Oath, No Spell" shares a chromosome or two with the material found on Good Morning, Magpie. It's upbeat and features melodious vocals. We then come to the album's first single, "I Came Around." It's a no-brainer why they chose this track for the single. There's no song catchier on the album==perhaps the catchiest single they've had since "Brother."

The latter half of the album gets more diverse. They pick up the pace with, "Hard World," which has Samantha Crain lending some of her vocals to the track. Musically, it's an interesting tone to hear from Murder by Death--sounding as if they drew influence from The Gaslight Anthem. However, it's not half as interesting as "Ditch Lilly." If Murder by Death had written a song with The Beatles during their White Album phase, this is what I imagine it would have sounded like. The band returns to the roaring 20's-esque sound similar to "On The Dark Streets Below." with the fiendish number, "The Curse of Elkhart," while "Ramblin'," throws in a bit of rockin' Americana.

The only song that doesn't seem to fit on the album is the instrumental track, "Queen Mab." As much as I love Murder by Death's instrumentals--and always look forward to them--this one just feels out of place. It comes at a bad time on the album and doesn't quite share the same ambiance as the rest of the record. There's a certain chill to it. The chills continue on "Go to the Light." Although the song's a little dull, I think fans of Like The Exorcist... will appreciate the blend of old with new. The same pace follows through to "Oh, to be an Animal," but it's much more a Lounge number. The record kind of regains focus on the closer, "Ghost Fields." The accordion has been sneaking in throughout the album, but it plays its biggest role here to enforce its wayfaring tone.

Bitter Drink, Bitter Moon loses itself halfway through, but finds itself in the end. For most albums, this would be a problem. There's something about Adam Turla's writing that actually works in its favor though. The reoccurring wander and lonesome themes that appear in Turla's storytelling go along with the different styles as a whole. It's like you're following a character into a number of different saloons that are playing different music. It's always exciting to see where Murder by Death will go with their albums--as they'll always do something different--and Bitter Drink, Bitter Moon was definitely something fresh while continually building off their previous works and now, I'm ready for another.

8.7 / 10Aaron H • October 9, 2012

See also

Murder By Death – Bitter Drink, Bitter Moon cover artwork
Murder By Death – Bitter Drink, Bitter Moon — Bloodshot, 2012

Related features

Murder By Death

Interviews • October 13, 2014

Murder By Death (III)

Interviews • May 6, 2012

Related news

Murder By Death 20th anniversary milestone

Posted in Tours on October 4, 2019

A Bloodshot Xmas

Posted in Records on October 21, 2017

New Murder By Death next year

Posted in Bands on December 6, 2014

More Murder By Death reviews browse all

Murder By Death

Who Will Survive, And What Will Be Left of Them?
Eyeball (2003)

I'll be honest right off the bat. The first mention I heard of Murder by Death was when they were making their name change from Little Joe Gould. I had yet to hear any music that the band plays, and my initial reaction was that based on namesake it was going to be another one of those emo-metalcore acts that … Read more

Murder By Death

In Bocca Al Lupo
East West/Tent Show (2006)

Music is an art, and oftentimes musicians will use their art to tell a story - concept albums have become increasingly popular in recent years. Murder by Death dabbled in this genre with their previous effort, Who Will Survive, And What Will Be Left of Them?. And while they have cast aside the extended storyline from their new full-length, In … Read more

Murder By Death

Red of Tooth and Claw
Vagrant (2008)

With their fourth full-length album, Murder by Death has finally brought all their varying influences together. Each of the band's previous recordings focused on a general indie rock sound, but they also flirted with various musical styles: folk, country, Americana, classical, and post-punk, among others. But with Red of Tooth and Claw all the band's previous flirtations and even some … Read more