Review
A Sense Of Porpoise
Self Titled

Independent (2012) — Nathan G. O'Brien

A Sense Of Porpoise – Self Titled cover artwork
A Sense Of Porpoise – Self Titled — Independent, 2012

Upon initial listen, this came across as the kind of sloppy folk punk that I’d likely be annoyed by if there was a male singer. Call me sexist if you will but the fact that a female is doing the vocals makes this totally pleasurable, whereas I’d normally dismiss such stuff after one listen as gimmicky coffee shop music that guys play around campfires, hoping to lure girls back to their van/tent/dirty sleeping bag by the river etc. Instead it’s grown on me completely – I keep finding myself going back to this one…even when I’m not burned-out on hip-hop and crust punk. I guess I just like it because it’s good music.

Based in Boulder, CO, the band is made up of two people: Ali Tadayon plays guitar, while Maggie McCarthy does vocals and plays banjo and accordion. This album features help from Robin Walker on percussion and Katie Conrad on viola and harmonica. It’s an easy copout to rely on comparisons, but I would be remiss if I didn’t mention the Moldy Peaches / Kimya Dawson-ness of this.

Most of the lyrics are lighthearted, goofy celebrations of youthful exuberance and life’s simpler pleasures, like backpacking beers, riding bikes and making out. It makes me smile to hear them firing a few harmless shots at Portland, OR in the songs “Mustache” and “No Parents.” Take for example the following line from the later: “Portland is fine if you like nice beer and vegans wearing leather - and smoking in some parking lot - and complaining about the weather.” I also like this one from “Loser”: “I am a tobacco user and an alcohol abuser. If these things make me a loser, then I guess my friends are too.” Pretty damn simple - pretty damn great.

A Sense Of Porpoise – Self Titled cover artwork
A Sense Of Porpoise – Self Titled — Independent, 2012

Recently-posted album reviews

Fontaines D.C.

Dopamine Chamber
XL Recordings (2026)

EP HIGHLIGHTS – “Tongue”, “Where Is Gone?”, “You Miss Me”, “Japan” If you’ve been here from the start, Fontaines D.C. will always conjure up gritty, political poetry and clashing, driving rhythms. Third album Skinty Fia, the defining breakthrough moment and fan favourite, gave them their first number one record in the UK and Ireland in 2022 – but can they … Read more

DeeCracks

True Nothing
Pirates Press (2026)

Let’s get crazy and out of control! That’s what the opening line of the album instructs us to do and I’m inclined to listen. I am new to the DeeCRACKS party and I’m not sure how I missed them. Celebrating 20 years in 2023, the band released 20 Years. A Frantic Effort, and I’m sure this newest release fully delivers … Read more

Massive Nightmares

Ain't My World
Black Numbers (2026)

Massive Nighmares debuted in 2024 with a short EP. Now they return with a full-length. The band plays a somewhat even blend of punk, emo, and alt-rock. As an example, check out "Up In Arms," which is like Dear You era Jawbreaker with a boost of power-pop and maybe some Lemonheads mixed in as well. While it's easily the poppiest … Read more