Review
Underoath
They're Only Chasing Safety

Tooth & Nail (2004) Carver

Underoath – They're Only Chasing Safety cover artwork
Underoath – They're Only Chasing Safety — Tooth & Nail, 2004

Within the world of science there exist certain absolutes that are ever-present and unchanging. While most of these laws are complex to the nth degree, even even the most common simpleton can understand a few of them. For example, the majority of the population knows that no matter how hard you try, oil and water will never mix. Similarly, with regards to music, everyone knows that hardcore can never be effectively blended with Christianity. After hearing endless attempts at doing this I was convinced that the task was impossible. The water and oil may never mix, but as far as the latter example is concerned; Underoath has conquered science.

Underoath delivers their fourth release, They're Only Chasing Safety , with a new singer, an updated sound, and a whole different attitude. The simplest way the band's new style can be described is 50% screaming/ and 50% melodic singing. Upon hearing the new vocal format, I anticipate that many fans will insist that the band has sold their souls by switching over to an increasingly popular melodic sound. However, I strongly believe that this type of response is bred primarily out of scene conformity, and that the person who makes this statement probably blasts the album in the car as soon as their hipster friends step out.

The content on the album is strong, beautiful, and at certain times very powerful. The themes are highly spiritual, but never exclusive. Directly or indirectly, the album provides questions, answers, and situations that any listener can relate to. I know this is the primary goal of nearly every album in existence, but often when a religious affiliation is slapped on an album people avoid it like the plague. Please don't miss out on this record, it exists to stimulate thoughts, not to convert beliefs.

As far as songs are concerned the best track on the album is "Reinventing Your Exit." The song is the best display of the new sound, and also the catchiest. Another spot of brilliance is "It's a Dangerous Business Walking Out Your Front Door." The song is less structured than the rest but has a very unique flavor. After three or so minutes of wild screaming a choir enters the track and repeatedly chants, "I'm drowning in sleep, I'm drowning in my sleep," before a dramatic conclusion.

They're Only Chasing Safety helps to eliminate some of the unfounded stereotypes which state that there can never be a credible union of music and spirituality. In addition, the album also shows us that it is possible for bands to change their sound and not destroy their careers in doing so. For these reasons, I deem this an important album.

9.0 / 10Carver • July 5, 2004

Underoath – They're Only Chasing Safety cover artwork
Underoath – They're Only Chasing Safety — Tooth & Nail, 2004

Related news

Underoath in 2023

Posted in Bands on March 4, 2023

New Underoath action

Posted in Records on September 25, 2021

Underoath adds Caspian to Rebirth Tour

Posted in Tours on January 20, 2016

More Underoath reviews

Underoath

Define the Great Line
Tooth & Nail (2006)

It's pretty commendable that a band like Underoath, who easily could be on a major label right now after their extremely successful breakout album They're Only Chasing Safety, chose to stay with their original label Tooth and Nail. Even more impressive however is that their latest outing, Define the Great Line, is significantly more mature in their songwriting style and … Read more