Feature / Interviews
Jack's Mannequin

Words: Graham Isador • Posted pre-2010

Scene Point Blank: Though it's obvious that you're writing music for your self, as your fan base increases and people become more and more fanatic, do you ever take into account that you're songs are going to be judged by other people?

Andrew McMahon: Um, no. It's a factor, but I think I can say I write for me first because I want to present something that I connect to, but on a universal level something others will connect to as well. I know that sounds a little backwards, because I say I'm doing it for myself, but that's how I like to write. The music I grew up listening to was largely pop and radio music. Not what I would consider pop in the sense that it lacks credibility but just music that was so well written that from one sense you could get that they were saying something that meant something to them, but also something that really did connect at a larger level.

I don't really feel a large sense to go beyond that and maybe find producers that are the " now/it" producers or try to really shoehorn myself into what's going on at the time. I think that's where I differ from some of my contemporary's who are going out of their way to fit the scene, or mold that's going on. Good song writing is good song writing and those songs will stand the test of time. I don't want to create music that intentionally sounds like something popular now, because my hope is that I can make songs that will be good enough to be successful on their ownâ?¦or at least successful enough that I can keep doing my job.

Scene Point Blank: You've spent the better part of your adult life playing music, and being more or less in the public eye. As all of this is so well documented, do you ever look back at what you've done, or something you put out a couple years ago, and cringe?

Andrew McMahon: I think that it happens, but it happens to every artist. When I do cringe, it's not with a lack of respect for what I've created in the past. I'm sitting there thinking, "I'm so young, I can't believe my voice sounded like that" or " Why did I think it was okay to say that?" You do it, and then you back off, and realize well that's where I was so of course I was going to say that. You grow, and you evolve, just like anybody does in his or her own life. Somebody who is a writer, a singer, or a painter, or anyone who does what they do on an artistic level leaves a trail of who they used to be.

You look back on it as the same way someone might look back on their teenage years and think "Can you believe the stupid shit we were doing?' Even my buddies and I look back on the stuff we did on the weekends in high school and just wonder how we ever thought that was cool. In that same way, sometimes you look back at what you did when you were seventeen or eighteen years old and it's incredibly profound and really say something about where you were at the time. You take that away and know that this song is a piece of me, it will always be a piece of me and I'm glad I said it.

Scene Point Blank: I remember some weekends friends and I spent throwing donuts at pedestriansâ?¦

Andrew McMahon: That used to be a huge part of our weekend, not the donut thing, but water-ballooning pedestrians. It was horrible. We'd run out of water balloons and just throw whatever takeout we had in the car. I remember this one time throwing a cup of guacamole at somebodyâ?¦

Scene Point Blank: Ketchup was always a favorite of mine.

Andrew McMahon: We had our asses handed to us one time by this high school football team. We were like fifteen at the time and could just drive and I made a mustard packet into this guy's window. He chased us down and stole our money and stuff. We stopped doing that after awhile.

Scene Point Blank: Me too. One thing I've been trying to do is get all the artists I've been talking with lately to pick one of their songs which they feel best defines them, what would be yours?

Andrew McMahon: I'd say "Made for Each Other."

Scene Point Blank: Parts one and two?

Andrew McMahon: Yeah. For me that track as a whole is really repetitive. And the reason I made it last on the record is because it spells out an over all philosophy. It definitely is in line with who I am, and what I believe.

Scene Point Blank: I haven't got much elseâ?¦um, if the moon were made out of barbeque spare ribs would you eat it?

Andrew McMahon: Would you eat it? Would you eat it?

Scene Point Blank: I know I would. In fact I've had seconds. Your thoughts?

Andrew McMahon: Cubs win! Cubs win! You've got your ear to the ground, Graham.

Scene Point Blank: Thanks a lot for everything, Andrew.


Words: Graham

Graphics: Matt

Related features

UK Subs

Interviews • August 23, 2026

50 Years of Chaos: Charlie Harper and the U.K. Subs More than five decades after the first sparks of punk lit up the U.K., Charlie Harper remains one of its most enduring figures. As the driving force behind U.K. Subs, Harper has seen entire scenes rise, fracture, and reinvent themselves … Read more

Commerce or Amusement? #2

Green Noise Records

Regular Columns / Commerce or Amusement? • August 22, 2026

Are You In The Music Business? Or Just Involved In Music? Interview Series #2. Featuring Martin Winch of Green Noise Records CC: Howdy Winch! Could you start off by telling the readers a little bit about yourself and Green Noise Records? How did you come to acquire it and what … Read more

Paths 2 Glory

One Question Interviews • August 19, 2026

Chris (Paths 2 Glory) SPB: What is your favorite Bad Religion song? Chris: It's hard to just have one favorite Bad Religion song. I have a few but the one that will always be my favorite or go to answer is "You." I first heard that song while playing Tony … Read more

The Sleights

One Question Interviews • August 18, 2026

Luke Blanton (The Sleights) SPB: Do you have any vinyl that you own strictly for collector’s purposes and never listen to? Blanton: I have never really bought a record specifically to collect it but I have bought a few records that ended up falling under that category. I was in … Read more

Dez Dare

One Question Interviews / What's That Noise? • August 17, 2026

Dez Dare talk about his studio gear including the Knas Moisturizer and Death By Audio's Echo Master and Space Ensemble.  Read more

Related news

Eagles Of Death Metal Video

Posted in Bands on June 23, 2004

Related reviews

Jack's Mannequin

The Glass Passenger
Sire (2008)

A lot of artists resist fame. I've done interviews with bands for nearly five years now and have heard countless times from both nameless and recognizable acts that there were never any aspirations for a hit radio single or a gold album. For these people it seemed when something reached a point of popularity it lost authenticity. By acknowledging the … Read more

More from this section

UK Subs

Interviews • August 23, 2026

50 Years of Chaos: Charlie Harper and the U.K. Subs More than five decades after the first sparks of punk lit up the U.K., Charlie Harper remains one of its most enduring figures. As the driving force behind U.K. Subs, Harper has seen entire scenes rise, fracture, and reinvent themselves … Read more

Stormtrooper

Interviews • August 10, 2026

Still a Dirty Mess: The Stormtrooper Oral History Before the Sex Pistols swore on television -- or tried to brush it off as "nothing, a rude word" -- and corporate labels commodified safety pins, there was a bar at The Marquee and a damp basement on King's Road. In 1975, … Read more

The Undead

Interviews • August 9, 2026

From shaping the early guitar drive of The Misfits to heading up The Undead, slinging bass for Times Square, and running Post Mortem Records out of a New Jersey bedroom, Bobby Steele’s footprint on tri-state punk is as real as it gets. He’s dodged precinct venue shutdowns, survived botched UK … Read more