Feature / Music
2009: A Year In Review

Words: Mitchell • Posted pre-2010

Top 5 Disappointments of 2009

ARTICLE JUMP

1. Weezer - Raditude

Christ.What happened here? The Red Album was fun and listenable: a few duds but some catchy tracks and witty ideas. This is just throwaway garbage. Where you used to be able to discount Rivers Cuomo's weirder moments on Weezer's recent output as examples of him subverting rock and roll paradigms, this is just the sound of a band phoning it in. The track with Lil Wayne sounds exactly like you think it's going to, and not in a good way, and the opening track "(If You're Wondering If I Want You To) I Want You To" is the album's best point. Rivers' perpetual 15 year old schtick is starting to be creepy instead of endearing, and this record epitomises it.

2. Green Day - 21st Century Breakdown

Interest in this record seems to have died off in the second half of 2009, thankfully. A much less interesting sequel to American Idiot, shat out by a band less concerned these days with heartfelt (if childish) lyrics, and more so with 'widening their boundaries', mistakenly thinking of themselves as genre-spanning heroes melding punk rock with stadium. The result is a boring and forgettable collection of songs that show none of the warmth of their earlier output. They don't have to write another Nimrod to please the critics, but the much-vaunted Warning was a great example of how to break the mould without sounding forced.

3. AFI - Crash Love

Davey and co supply us with an album shifted even further toward the pop/rock spectrum, gradually subtracting all of the elements that made AFI good: catharsis, depth and texture. While this still has their increasingly-prevalent flamboyance and showmanship, it also sees Havok's lyrics faltering for the first time as he attempts to widen his scope, firing off poorly-aimed shots at religion, and penning embarrassing lovenotes to Winona Ryder. The urgency and darkness is gone, replaced by plasticy efforts at enthusiasm.

4. NOFX - Coaster

It's perhaps too obvious to critique an album specifically named to suggest its throwaway nature, but this smacked of a band trying too hard to perform the trick they've perfected over their last half dozen records. Songs struggling to do the 'funny punk' thing, and some more weak attacks on organised religion, and we have a NOFX album by numbers.

5. Death By Stereo - Death Is My Only Friend

Cheesy hard rock, radio-friendly choruses, awful string-laden ballads and a re-recording of an already poor song. What is it with bands from California wanting to piss all over their discography? Skip this and head straight for Into the Valley of Death.

(Matt)

Related features

Unseemlier

One Question Interviews • June 27, 2025

Mike Assatly (Unseemlier - guitar/vocals) SPB: Do you have a preferred model of van for touring? Assatly: Chevy G-20 Gladiator! It was my first van, I got it from my uncle with 115,000 on it. He got rid of it for a new van because it was "old" and would … Read more

Dollar Store

One Question Interviews • June 26, 2025

Dave Slaverave (Dollar Store - bass) SPB: This band hits a lot of styles, all kind of overlapping at the same time. How hard was it to find “your sound” when bringing these influences together? Slaverave: Not very hard at all actually. We're all old-ass adults who've soaked in a … Read more

Golden Shitters

One Question Interviews • June 25, 2025

Matt (Golden Shitters) How nervous were you the first time you played a show? My first show was around 2002. I was 15 years old and it was a basement house party in my hometown of Welland, Ontario. I’d just proved myself to my high school buddies by singing The … Read more

Arms Aloft

Interviews • June 23, 2025

Remember Election Day 2024? Maybe you shouldn't. Maybe you've blocked it out. That's fair, but there was one pleasant surprise that day: a new EP from Wisconsin's Arms Aloft. It took a while to claw out of the darkness in November, then Year End 2024 coverage took over the Scene … Read more

Small Steps

One Question Interviews • June 12, 2025

Jeremiah (Small Steps - guitar/vocals) SPB: What song has the best use of whistling? Jeremiah: I feel like the easy answer would be the Bobby McFerrin song "Don't Worry Be Happy". Which is catchy as all get out, but we prefer the road less traveled here in Small Steps. For … Read more

More from this section

Caterwaul 2025

Music • May 13, 2025

Each year in late May, the 4-day party and noise-rock festival Caterwaul takes over multiple venues in Minneapolis. It’s a stacked lineup this year, to put it mildly, with each night’s headliners FACS, Young Widows, Naw, Pissed Jeans, and Uniform -- and that’s leaving a ton of other great bands … Read more

Guest List: Steven Fairweather (Gob) – The Gateway And The Getaway

Music / The Set List • May 13, 2025

Steven Fairweather is a Canadian musician, radio show host, and comic book writer. He is best known as the bassist of the punk band Gob and the founder of Stranger Radio, an independent online radio station. -- Before the internet, before streaming, before Shazam could tell you what was playing … Read more

2024: A Year In Review

Music / Year End 2024 • January 13, 2025

It's a new year – hooray. And things are off to a fine start, too. If the thought of corrupt governments, AI domination, unmoderated social networks and endless war is causing you to retreat into the past, we don't blame you. In fact, we encourage it! Our writers have summed … Read more