Review
Madvillain
Madvillainy

Stones Throw (2004) Jonathan

Madvillain – Madvillainy cover artwork
Madvillain – Madvillainy — Stones Throw, 2004

On this highly anticipated release from arguably two of underground hip-hop's most interesting personalities- wunderkind producer/MC Madlib (a.k.a. Otis Jackson, Jr., Quasimoto, Yesterday's New Quintet) and eccentric rapper MF Doom (a.k.a. Daniel Dumile, Viktor Vaughn, King Geedorah, Zevlove X) combine each of their unique talents to create an undeniably challenging and masterfully constructed record.

Although there's an unquestionable cohesion to each of the twenty-two tracks, an almost disjointed quality hangs over the proceedings. The result is an effect similar to a single long song cobbled together from various sessions- albeit a single, long, intensely captivating song. This doesn't come as a surprise, considering the tracks that would eventually constitute Madvillainy originated from a variety of source demos Madlib had been kicking around and, subsequently, have been kicking around the darker corners of the world wide web for a time.

From beginning to end, MF Doom's trademark smoky, grizzled, vaguely seductive delivery remains simultaneously inviting and world-weary. This is especially true on tracks like "Meat Grinder" and "Curls", where he lays down such words of wisdom as: "villain get the money like curls/they just tryin' to get a nut like squirrels in this mad world/land of milk and honey with the swirls/where reckless nekkid girls/get necklaces of pearls". Despite the fact that Madvillainy feels largely like Madlib's baby, Doom's exceedingly original and often brilliant wordplay paint complex portraits of a variety of topics and, in the process, manage to anchor the production quite effectively.

On the production side of the deal, Madlib's beats are consistently laidback and inventive, showcasing a bit more grit, emotion, and humor than ever before (check out the hilarious samples littered throughout "America's Most Blunted"). The production also appears to tread a similar path as his work on last year's Shades of Blue (an album on which he was afforded unregulated access to the Blue Note archives), conveying just enough to keep things interesting but never so much that the beats overshadow the rhymes. Moreover, the production manages to incorporate a number of diverse genres without ever coming off as gimmicky or contrived.

Even though it's barely April, Madvillainy is a strong contender for hip-hop record of the year. Hell, even the album art is great! A truly inspiring testament to the work two visionaries at the pinnacles of their respective games can accomplish. I certainly hope this isn't the last collaboration we hear from these two characters.

8.9 / 10Jonathan • April 5, 2004

Madvillain – Madvillainy cover artwork
Madvillain – Madvillainy — Stones Throw, 2004

Related news

Madvillain entry in the 33 1/3 series

Posted in Music News on February 14, 2023

Madvillain Working On New Album

Posted in Records on October 30, 2009

Recently-posted album reviews

The Penske File

Reprieve
Gunner Records, Stomp Records (2025)

I used to dislike punk music where people sing. And, well, I'm still not super fond of it but there is an exception to every rule. The Penske File are one of those exceptions and maybe it's because while they have a singer (as compared to a "vocalist"), it's still authentic and conveys that everyperson vibe I seek in the … Read more

Menace Ruine

The Color of the Grave Is Green
Union Finale Records (2025)

One of the most unique voices in extreme music, Menace Ruine stand out in their sonic evolution. The duo of Geneviève Beaulieu and Steve de la Moth started out in a raw, uncompromising fashion, merging black metal and industrial to create absolute havoc in Cult of Ruins and The Die is Cast. In the coming years, they would expand this … Read more

Extortionist

Stare Into The Seething Wounds
Unique Leader (2025)

With a band name like Extortionist, you instantly know they aren’t messing around. I’ve watched enough true crime documentaries to know when you’re going to get tangled up with someone you shouldn’t. Hailing from the Pacific Northwest, this band gives you exactly what you want and expect – raw, merciless and unforgiving music. Looking at the cover art and their … Read more