Review
Coreline
Bone and Blood as Stone and Mud

Sonic Mainline (2009) Matt T.

Coreline – Bone and Blood as Stone and Mud cover artwork
Coreline – Bone and Blood as Stone and Mud — Sonic Mainline, 2009

There's something very important one has to keep in mind when reviewing a Coreline album, or indeed merely when listening to it. And that is this:

The brain that gave birth to this is one fully capable of rickrolling an entire festival audience, in amongst a performance that also delivers a theater troupe performing in cardboard robot costumes. Tongue in cheek is the order of the day.

With that in mind, let's suspend our serious music review hat for a second. Coreline's debut album Please Keep Moving Forward was a mish-mash of styles both subtle and gloriously trashy. Almost eurodance-esque synth lines held into place by clattering beats and weaved through with a pseudo-IDM sense of disorder. It was certainly not for everyone, but it equally certainly didn't get the attention it deserved within the British alternative electronica scene.

It's therefore understandable that for the follow-up album, Bone and Blood as Stone and Mud, Chris Coreline has decided to try and mollify the chin-strokers with a more straight-laced mix of his earlier ingredients in a collection of songs that are simultaneously both more accomplished and less engaging than earlier material. Album opener "Coreline Builds Better Robots" is really the only track on the album to contain the infectious sense of what-the-hell that the debut release represented, having drafted in a school choir to sing the title line over the top of '80s synths and meaty shuffling percussion hits. The technical abilities behind the compositions are much more apparent this time round, discordant melodies and chaotic beats sliding over each other with a sci-fi frictionless ease.

Elsewhere the album hits a strong midsection, with the likes of "This is Industrial Baroque" and "This is Not a Love Song" taking Coreline's orchestral affectations to further extremes. While there's no particular point where the songs fail to make an impact, there's a definite sense of blending into the surroundings. In adopting many of the more stripped-back elements of the current scene, there's a danger that a unique identifier has been lost. There is one experimental misfire in album closer "The Middle," where beats and synthlines have been fused with singer-songwriter style acoustics and vocals. Strangely this actually pushes the strengths of Coreline to the fore, as the electronic elements of the song walk proudly head and shoulders above the pedestrian efforts of collaborator David Lawrie.

There's a likelihood that this iteration of Coreline could well find a much stronger following than with the more nascent, energetic and let's face it cheesy material that has previously been released. It's a decent hard electronic (or whatever the kids are calling it these days) release, but feels somewhat watered down for ease of listening.

6.9 / 10Matt T. • August 4, 2009

See also

Ah Cama-Sotz, Pow[D]Er Pussy

Coreline – Bone and Blood as Stone and Mud cover artwork
Coreline – Bone and Blood as Stone and Mud — Sonic Mainline, 2009

Recently-posted album reviews

Between the Buried and Me

The Blue Nowhere
Inside Out (2025)

Between The Buried And Me are seasoned vets to the progressive metalcore, electronic, prog (whatever other genre they bend) scene and continue to drop album after album. Their career started back in 2000 from the ashes of one of the greatest metalcore bands of all time (in my humble opinion), Prayer For Cleansing. As the band has progressed over the … Read more

The Beths

Straight Line Was A Lie
Anti (2025)

Dear Beths, Congratulations on the new release. I’ve been reflecting on our relationship and, as I’ve recently started to write about music again, have been asked to share my thoughts with you. First and foremost, I want to say that this isn’t easy for me. I cherish your album Future Me Hates Me from 2018. The title track alone is … Read more

East End Redemption

Crashing Down
Independent (2025)

Who would’ve thought that from the land of lobsters and blueberries, you’d find a punk band? East End Redemption is a four-piece band that brings their flavor of punk from Portland, Maine to the masses with their eleven song, debut full-length album, Crashing Down. They mix elements of skate punk, power pop, and even hints of hardcore punk. The band … Read more