Review
Craig Finn
Clear Heart/Full Eyes

Vagrant (2012) Loren

Craig Finn – Clear Heart/Full Eyes cover artwork
Craig Finn – Clear Heart/Full Eyes — Vagrant, 2012

Clear Heart Full Eyes starts off curiously. Sure, “Apollo Bay” establishes that Finn’s solo debut is a separate project compared with The Hold Steady, but it’s also a minimal and boring song—among the worst and most forgettable on the record. He speaksings over a wandering guitar with some occasional slide that ultimately gets repetitive: something I won’t say about the rest of the record. I think it’s supposed to give an air of roving through a wasteland, but mostly it just makes me tune out for five minutes.

The intro track, though, is misleading. While built around Texas session musicians and a humid, lonely streak befitting of that geography, the rest of the album successfully mixes up sounds and characters (Finn’s strength), while alternately branching out from his popular main band.

The start is slow, but it picks up with the somber yet up-tempo “No Future” and really gets moving on “New Friend Jesus,” a bluegrass-styled song that’s a bit repetitive and heavy-handed, but the tempo change really defines the rest of the album. It leads into “Jackson,” which is a highlight with its storytelling narration. The music starts out minimal but builds, twists, and rises along with the narration, peaking as the storyline develops. Finn’s narration has long been his strength, and even with the varied (read: quieter) instrumentation, it’s the lyrics that shine. My growing gripe with Hold Steady releases is the wanky guitar solos, and their absence here is appreciated. Another lyrical highlight is “Balcony,” a country ballad with a lot of slide guitar and peppered with Minnesota-centric lyrics.

The downside isn’t so much the tempo and the tone but the balance and sequencing. Finn has never been much of a singer, and while he’s improved his chops over the years, the record still comes across as monotone over eleven songs. The instrumentation does what it can to mix things up, with organ and slide guitar giving some variety where his voice cannot. Still, it gets a bit drab on a start to finish listen in a way that louder rock, as with The Hold Steady, suits him better. There are definitely some choice cuts here, but as a whole it feels a bit sleepy and forgettable.

6.7 / 10Loren • June 11, 2012

Craig Finn – Clear Heart/Full Eyes cover artwork
Craig Finn – Clear Heart/Full Eyes — Vagrant, 2012

Related news

Dave Hause curates a music festival

Posted in Shows on January 26, 2023

Craig Finn shares "Messing With The Settings"

Posted in Records on March 25, 2022

Craig Finn releases single in advance of tour

Posted in Bands on October 5, 2019

Recently-posted album reviews

Painkiller

The Great God Pan
Tzadik (2025)

Painkiller, the trio of John Zorn, Bill Laswell, and Mick Harris shows no signs of slowing down. The Great God Pan is their third full-length, since their reunion in 2024, and in many ways it is an unexpected offering. In keeping with their interests in the metaphysical realm, Painkiller find inspiration from the famed Arthur Machen horror novella. Here, the … Read more

Painkiller

The Equinox
Tzadik (2025)

Painkiller sees three absolute masters of extreme music join forces. John Zorn of Naked City and a billion other projects, Mick Harris who transcended from Napalm Death drummer to illbient guru with Scorn, and producer extraordinaire Bill Laswell. Their first two records, Guts of a Virgin and Buried Secrets are strange meditations traversing between free-jazz, grindcore and dub. Still hungry … Read more

Dauber

Falling Down
Dromedary Records, Recess (2025)

The lazy approach would be to call Dauber "ex-Screaming Females," but that barely scratches the surface. If I had to pick one band to namedrop a comparison to, it would be labelmates Night Court. They play a familiar style but with a lot of quirks that set it apart from the genre standard-bearers. It's driving and energetic -- more importantly, … Read more