Review
Creature Feature
The Greatest Show Unearthed

Sumerian (2007) Kevin Fitzpatrick

Creature Feature – The Greatest Show Unearthed cover artwork
Creature Feature – The Greatest Show Unearthed — Sumerian, 2007

When reviewing an album, it can be difficult to summarize thoughts and feeling elicited from the music you're listening to, to organize these thoughts and feelings in written prose succinctly, honestly, and, above all, professionally. Using these guidelines as my template, I can say with all sincerity, fuck me running, this group is terrible. Creature Feature is the "brain"child of two dudes who, I would bet my bottom dollar still live in their parents' basement. What they attempt to create is, according to their bio, "a band that forces you remember why you used to sleep with the lights on, a band that becomes the perfect merger of music and film." Sweet Jesus, what a crock of shit. What they in fact, deliver is music that's not scary, fun, or clever. The Greatest Show Unearthed boasts songs like "Aim for the Head," "Buried Alive," (unfortunately not a Venom cover, though I shudder to think what these clown's version would sound like), and "A Corpse in My Bed." Never before have a guitar and synth duo sounded more like a guitar and synth duo. Oh wait there's sampling. Sampled drums, that is. Courtesy of what can only be described as a Roland TR-808 knock-off. Perfect if you're in a Sugarhill Gang tribute band, not so much a horror pop group. So we put this all together with a Tom DeLonge wannabe vocalist and poorly recreated (oh, Casio is there anything you can't do?) Theremin sounds. Not spooky enough? Wait there's more! You get really cool artwork that may or not be stolen from the EGreetings.com Halloween collection. To their credit, they seem to like horror movies. To their detriment, they make liking horror movies seem really, really lame. Horror themed music can be done to great effect, whether it's horror-punk (Misfits), horror-metal (Rob Zombie, old Marilyn Manson), or horror-pop (the uh…Horrorpops). The only scary thing about Creature Feature is that they actually seem to have a fanbase that likes this circus-y horror dreck that isn't even good accidentally. If it were sent to Blender Magazine, it would, most assuredly make their "Albums We Didn't Even Open" list. But I made the ultimate sacrifice and opened it for you our dear readers so you wouldn't have to be subjected to the lameness contained therein. No, no… no thanks are necessary. I know you'd do the same for me. All I ask is that you listen to me and heed these preceding words and run far away from this shitty, shitty album.

Creature Feature – The Greatest Show Unearthed cover artwork
Creature Feature – The Greatest Show Unearthed — Sumerian, 2007

Related features

5 Horrorpunk Songs For Your Halloween Party Playlist

Music / The Set List • October 30, 2022

Recently-posted album reviews

Action/Adventure

Ever After
Pure Noise (2025)

Chicago’s Action/Adventure have been grinding the pop-punk trenches since 2014. They have always played pop-punk like it still has something to prove because for them, it does. They went viral in 2020 on TikTok with their song “Barricades” by calling out the exact thing no one in the scene wanted to say out loud. The genre is full of white … Read more

217

In Your Gaze
Time To Kill (2025)

If you didn’t know, hardcore and punk are alive and thriving in Italy. When I come across bands from there, their scene never ceases to amaze me. Italy gave us Raw Power and Negazione in the ’80s, Slander and Strength Approach in the 2010s. Now 217 picks up that lineage with their own mix of fire and reflection by keeping … Read more

Ugly Stick

Absinthe
Hovercraft Records (2025)

Contrary to what I said on Vh1’s Behind the Music, Tim from Hovercraft is one of my favourite human beings. I suppose in some ways that’s not saying much but Tim plays in one of my favourite bands, I’m a fan of his art and on top of those two things and running a label, his day job is saving … Read more