Review
Earth Girls
Wrong Side of History

Grave Mistake (2014) Nathan G. O'Brien

Earth Girls – Wrong Side of History cover artwork
Earth Girls – Wrong Side of History — Grave Mistake, 2014

Wrong Side of History is the debut 7” by Chicago upstarts Earth Girls. This piece of weighty green wax (via Grave Mistake in the United States) was recorded during the same session as their sold-out limited run demo cassette from earlier this year. Earth Girls are headed up by Liz Panella of Libyans and Broken Prayer on guitar and vocals. The lineup is rounded out by Joey Kappel, also of Broken Prayer as well as Boilerman, on bass, and Jeff Rice of Daylight Robbery on drums. Although the photograph that’s used for the front and the back of the jacket shows four people, Earth Girls recorded this material as a three piece, with Panella playing both lead and rhythm guitar. 

Eschewing the aggressiveness of Libyans or the outright weirdness of Broken Prayer, Earth Girls is quite a bit different from Panella’s other bands. These songs are a fun and soothing blend of melodic punk and sun-stroked garage rock. It hits somewhere between Radioactivity/Marked Men territory and the aforementioned Daylight Robbery, while faintly recalling ‘90s alt acts like Belly.

There’s a uniqueness to these songs that’s as hard to nail down as it is captivating. The opening track “Unavailable” has this strange rolling melody to it that makes me think Panella sang it without any accompaniment and then they constructed the musical arrangement around her vocals. The guitars on “Drag it Out” are simple yet awesome; alternating between higher pitched jangle and fuzzy chugging that pulls you in and demands you wriggle in delight. There are fleeting moments throughout the four tracks here that Panella lets loose a bit to showcase her vocal range; not as bluesy as Mia Zapata or as abrasive as Kathleen Hanna, but somewhere in between, and always incredibly enchanting. 

Very much like Koko Beware’s 2012 album Something About Summer, there’s a certain aura about Wrong Side of History that really radiates a feeling of sunshine, boozy late nights, carefree living, and the youthful enthusiasm that comes with this time of year. And unfortunately, like the summer months, this one is over far too quickly.

Earth Girls – Wrong Side of History cover artwork
Earth Girls – Wrong Side of History — Grave Mistake, 2014

Related news

Drunken Sailor represses OWTH/Discharge split

Posted in Records on July 28, 2014

Recently-posted album reviews

Generacion Suicida

Hombre Nuevo
Vitriol (2026)

On the tail end of Autogramm’s 2018 tour of Mexico (what little I remember of that week now is a lot of pulque and not a lot of sleep) I visited the one punk record store in CDMX that I found via googling where to buy bootleg punk t-shirts. I’d already visited Venas Rotas Discos earlier on the trip and … Read more

Karen Dió

Fugaz
Hopeless (2026)

Six songs. That's all Karen Dió needs on this EP. Considering the title translates roughly to fleeting, brief, or transient in Portuguese, maybe that's exactly the point. Dió's second EP doesn't hang around long enough to overstay its welcome. It arrives, makes a hell of a lot of noise, throws some gigantic hooks at you, and disappears. But there's considerably … Read more

Real Numbers

Was It Always This Way
Slumberland Records (2026)

I feel like this may be the first 12", 10-song release in my collection from Real Numbers, a dreampop meets jangle-indie rock band from Minneapolis. I'm not going to fact check my statement, because I mean it as a metaphor. Real Numbers play exactly what you'd expect based on my short description so far, but there's always something just a … Read more