Review
Gone is Gone
Echolocation

Rise (2017) Kevin Fitzpatrick

Gone is Gone – Echolocation cover artwork
Gone is Gone – Echolocation — Rise, 2017

Mastodon are no stranger to side projects. Hell, guitarist/vocalist Brent Hinds has released two in the last year alone, with his new Legend of the Seagullmen album due in September. Brann Dailor released Arcadea, also on this years’ top 25 list, and Bill Kelliher doesn’t need your goddamn validation!

Gone is Gone is the amalgamation of Mastodon bassist/vocalist Troy Sanders, guitarist Troy Van Leeuwen of Queens of the Stone Age, drummer Tony Hajjar of At the Drive-In and multi-instrumentalist Mike Zarin. 

On paper, it shouldn’t work. Vastly different backgrounds and styles more often than not create a cacophony rather than a tranquility. But because Echolocation is very much the latter, is a testament to just how talented and multi-faceted the musicians involved really are. 

Opening track “Sentient” serves almost as an Isis-esque prelude to the album to come. “Gift” follows and is much more indicative of Echolocation’s groove-laden style, invoking whispers of Alice In Chains and Deftones. “Slow Awakening” is possibly Sanders’ finest vocal performance to date - sounding like an even more ominous Peter Steele. These touchstones are merely to give you an idea of what to expect. The thing is, once the listener tries to hold on that idea of familiarity, they realize they’re grasping at smoke and are left with something much more tangible and wholly unique.

What’s interesting is the journey each member takes with every passing tune. Where they each start at the beginning of a song, is not where they end up by thelat note. Take “Pawns” for example. It starts out very clearly with Sanders and Hajjar in the drivers’ seat, but by the time it fades out, it’s clearly Van Leeuwen driving the bus and we were none the wiser. 

Van Leeuwen is really the beautiful surprise in all of this. His guitar work has become so synonymous with the QOTSA sound, you forget how heterogeneous his talent really is. Van Leeuwen also earns the distinction of this reviewers’ 2017 Top 25 hat-trick award - making appearances on Echolocation, Chelsea Wolfe’s Hiss Spun and Queens of the Stone Age’s Villains.

Gone is Gone – Echolocation cover artwork
Gone is Gone – Echolocation — Rise, 2017

Related news

Gone Is Gone forms (ATDI, QOTSA, Mastodon)

Posted in Bands on April 16, 2016

Recently-posted album reviews

The Devil Wears Prada

Flowers
Solid State (2025)

Twenty years into the grind and The Devil Wears Prada haven’t lost their edge. However, in recent years, it’s a bit more refined and less jagged than their earlier release. The band’s latest release, Flowers, feels like their sharpest, most well-oiled bloom yet. From the opening track “That Same Place” to the closing “My Paradise”, this record is a reckoning. … Read more

DFMK

Playa Nuclear
Alternative Tentacles (2025)

DFMK have been playing since 2009, but Playa Nuclear is just their second full-length. It kicks off with exactly what I expect of the band in "Mi Rutina" -- a driving punk song with lots of high energy, guitar-driven bridges; Mr. Cap on vocals and doing near-splits between songs; and a general melodic flow that balances nervous energy with a … Read more

Action/Adventure

Ever After
Pure Noise (2025)

Chicago’s Action/Adventure have been grinding the pop-punk trenches since 2014. They have always played pop-punk like it still has something to prove because for them, it does. They went viral in 2020 on TikTok with their song “Barricades” by calling out the exact thing no one in the scene wanted to say out loud. The genre is full of white … Read more