Reviews Plow United Marching Band

Plow United

Marching Band

After a run from 1992-1998, Plow United reformed in 2011 and they return with new material in the form of Marching Band (Jump Start Records). Plow United hasn’t just re-formed, they’ve written the best 1990s record of the 2010s. Brian McKee’s voice has matured with the years and the songs are tighter and more polished than their early output. Some of that youthful poise is lost, replaced with a more community-focused approach. Fans will notice a difference from the Sleep Walk songs but not a massive departure in sound. It’s short and punchy, with more slogan-style lyricism and a less personalized/first-person tone. It takes modern beard punk sensibilities and lends then toward 1990s choral refrains and social causes.

The record is pop-punk at its core, brought down to elemental levels of repetition, group singalongs, and corralling universal emotions into a catchy slogan. All of the above makes it sound like this record isn’t unique, but that isn’t the case either; it just fits well within a certain confine. The songs carry a nice frontman presence from McKee as the songs build in energy and come together for the chorus. It’s verse-chorus-verse, with a definite focus on lyricism. At times it gets jingoistic, as in “The War Is Over and Our Side Won,” but it’s in “that preach to the choir/let’s celebrate” fashion—more of a post-World Series exclamation than a pulpit finger-waving. The point of view is definitely in establishing bigger picture topical points rather than personalizing it and the tone can be summarized well with the closing lyrics of “The World Is a Slum,” where they state: “It’s just as naïve to say everyone sucks/ as is it to think everyone’s kind” Curiously I associate this sloganizing as a 1990s remnant, but it feels more prevalent on Marching Band than in their older material.

While the songs follow a fairly set blueprint, they mix up progressions, vocal inflections, tempos, and melodies enough to avoid the sameness that buries a lot of pop-punk (you won’t find any Lookout Records comparisons here). Drummer Sean Rule is a big contributor, and the clean production gives the percussion a stronger force in the mix. On a down note, the guest vocals in “The World Is a Slum,” are rather grating, quickly driving the song into the discard pile.

That’s just one misstep though, and really Plow United has released a kicker of a record, their first in 14 years. Usually when a band reunites, the new songs feel stale or forced. Here, it feels like nothing but relentless heart coming from the band.

7.5 / 10Loren
Tor Johnson Records
Leave a comment

Jump Start


7.5 / 10

7.5 / 10

Share this content
Related features

One Question Interviews Plow United

Posted Jan. 24, 2015, 12:58 a.m.

Joel Tannenbaum (Plow United, The Rentiers, Ex Friends) SPB: As a musician, do you find terminology such as “side project” to be relevant to you ...

Radio K 2
Recent reviews


Beautiful Ruin

8.0 / 10 Converge - Beautiful Ruin album cover

Converge—Nietzsche’s pissed off nephew, Rilke’s furious friend—achieves a glimmering consummation in a mishmash of fourness (which, in numerology, symbolizes spiritual wholeness). They went from thrash titans to sonic gods; now ...



7.8 / 10 Northwoods - Wasteland  album cover

'[T]here the nightingale filled all the desert with inviolable voice and still she cried, and still the world pursues, "Jug Jug" to dirty ears.' And likewise, with dirty ears, the ...

The Bils

Past Masters: Volume 1

6.5 / 10 The Bils - Past Masters: Volume 1 album cover

The Bils are Bil and Michelle Bilson, a husband-wife duo that play laid back rock schooled by classic duets. Depending which paragraph of their press sheet you’re reading, they are ...

Related news

Records Plow United and The Headies split

Posted April 2, 2015, 5:29 p.m.

Plow United and The Headies have announced a split 7" on Self Aware Records, with pre-orders available now. As the press sheet notes, "The members of these two bands have ...

Bands 1QI: Ampere, Plow United, Recreant, United Teachers of Music

Posted Jan. 24, 2015, 9:39 a.m.

Welcome to our almost daily quickie Q&A feature: One Question Interviews. Follow us at facebook or twitter and we'll post one interview every Monday-Thursday. Okay, sometimes we miss ...

Shows Plow United and Mikey Erg New Year's Eve show

Posted Dec. 13, 2014, 5:30 p.m.

Plow United will be playing a New Year's Eve show at World Cafe Live at the Queen in Wilmington, DE on Dec. 31, with Mikey Erg, The Headies, and ...



Looking for the SPB logo? You can download it in a range of styles and colours here:

Click anywhere outside this dialog to close it, or press escape.