Review
Slingshot Dakota
Their Dreams are Dead, but Ours is the Golden Ghost

Independent (2008) Jason

Slingshot Dakota – Their Dreams are Dead, but Ours is the Golden Ghost cover artwork
Slingshot Dakota – Their Dreams are Dead, but Ours is the Golden Ghost — Independent, 2008

A few years ago I went to one of those parties that a lot of us have attended. There was plenty of PBR flowing and occupants had their fair share of scarves on. Yes, it was a hipster party and I was miserable. The girls there were all too young for me to bother hitting on and all the guys were talking about bands I neither cared about nor ever heard of. Eventually one of these drunken dudes wouldn't stop talking about this married duo called Mates of State and forced me at broken beer bottle point to watch a DVD of the band. What followed were some keyboard driven cutesy pop songs that couldn't rock their way out a wet paper bag. I vowed never to hear another indie-pop duo so long as I lived.

Fast forward to 2008, life is short and I'm listening to yet another indie-pop dual. I wasn't forced into hearing Slingshot Dakota this time. I actually wanted to hear them ever since I heard the drummer of the underrated but appreciated Latterman left the band to start Slingshot Dakota. Chicks, man, they make you do crazy things. Unlike, Mates of State I don't know if Slingshot Dakota members Carly and Tom are married or even dating, but why else would anyone stop being in Latterman?

Alright, I'm being a gossip-ridden dick. I have no idea if Latterman broke up with Tom forming Slingshot Dakota with Carly, but I always have to be bitter about something when bands break up. Remember when Lifetime broke up and Ari started that awful Zero Zero with his wife? Same thing. Sorry; I'll get over it.

Back to the Mates of State comparison, which I'm sure Slingshot Dakota gets a lot of since they are both comprised a male drummer and a female keyboard player. They also both play darling little pop tunes full of songs about living rooms, hearts, and being all giddy like schoolgirls. If the next nerdy babe I convince to date me doesn't include "Until the Day I Die" on a mixtape, I might feel a little offended.

I haven't bothered to listen to Mates of State since the fabled night at Hipster Hangout #2124545 and I probably never will. However, Slingshot Dakota I like. I can't deny the fact that this duo writes some really catchy songs. I found myself humming a bar or two at the bank and trying to remember where it came from. Then I got embarrassed when I remembered. Sure the keyboards are a bit much and everything down to packaging reeks of adorableness but you know what? I can be sappy sometimes and Their Dreams are Dead, But Ours is the Golden Ghost fills that part of me when it's needed. If you see me skipping down the street licking a lollipop hand in hand with a pigtailed cutesy this probably is our soundtrack. And that probably will never happen. Nevertheless, in case it does, I'll be keeping this CD around.

7.5 / 10Jason • May 8, 2008

Slingshot Dakota – Their Dreams are Dead, but Ours is the Golden Ghost cover artwork
Slingshot Dakota – Their Dreams are Dead, but Ours is the Golden Ghost — Independent, 2008

Related news

Breakin' Even Fest Gettin' Ready

Posted in Shows on February 12, 2016

Slingshot Dakota Post New Demos / Fugazi Cover

Posted in MP3s on June 24, 2009

Stream Entire Slingshot Dakota Album

Posted in MP3s on January 22, 2008

Recently-posted album reviews

The Cascadian Divide

To the Sky
Independent (2026)

The Cascadian Divide is a Washington state based melodic skate punk band that formed during the infamous COVID lockdown. Although it started as an experiment, it soon became a passion project for the band members. The band has seen its share of line up changes over the years, but the commitment to maintaining the sound and integrity of the band … Read more

Jungle Rot

Cruel Face Of War
Unique Leader (2026)

Twelve albums and more than three decades into their career, Jungle Rot remains one of death metal's most reliable institutions. While countless bands have spent years chasing technical excess, progressive experimentation, or whatever trend happens to be dominating the underground now, the Kenosha veterans have remained committed to a simpler mission. Writing memorable riffs, locking into crushing grooves, and leaving … Read more

Overcalc

Fruits of the Decision Tree
Sleeping Giant Glossolalia (2024)

Some instrumental records create atmosphere while others create movement. Fruits of the Decision Tree feels like it creates an entire environment. It’s unstable, mechanical, strangely beautiful, and constantly in motion. The solo project of Nick Skrobisz (Multicult, The Wayward), Overcalc exists somewhere between electronic experimentation, prog-level guitar precision, ambient drift, and full on sci-fi hallucination. Trying to pin it cleanly … Read more