Review / 200 Words Or Less
Sticks N Stones
Is It You?

Trouble In Mind (2010) — Loren

Sticks N Stones – Is It You? cover artwork
Sticks N Stones – Is It You? — Trouble In Mind, 2010

Trouble in Mind is getting to the point with their cover art. The point is: let the music stand for itself. Or maybe it’s just a copout since they think everybody will download it instead. Anyway, with their fifteenth release, the label sticks to their favored style: Midwestern pop-flavored garage. Sticks N Stones may stick rather firmly to genre conventions, but they do so well and the two songs on Is It You? offer upbeat, positive jams you can both singalong and dance to if that’s your thing.

The Milwaukee band likes their chords big and their choruses catchy—utilizing the refrain in the song title and offering some big breakdowns and cymbal crashes. On A-side “Is It You?” singer Paul Kalfahs puts forth rhetorical lyrics while bassist Natalie Clark piles on the harmonies. The power pop is delivered through a veil of distortion, but not enough to muddle the sunshine coming through the melody. Overall, it’s peppy, pleasant, and familiar.

B-side “Telling the Truth” follows a similar format, with Kalfahs taking the lead until the chorus, where he’s joined with group vocals. The guitars stick to basic chords while Clark’s bass jumps around just enough to give the song some texture without straying too far from its roots. It’s the sort of music you can singalong to on first listen, yet are unable to explain the content if asked—the melody dominates and the guitar rules.

For being their second release it shows promise, but the confines of the genre limit its appeal. Maybe a full length would offer more variety than a single. Of the two songs, “Is It You?” definitely sticks out as the more memorable, making it a good choice for side A.

6.8 / 10 — Loren • January 24, 2011

Sticks N Stones – Is It You? cover artwork
Sticks N Stones – Is It You? — Trouble In Mind, 2010

Recently-posted album reviews

PeelingFlesh

PeelingFlesh
Unique Leader (2026)

I went into Oklahoma quintet PeelingFlesh’s self-titled sophomore album out of genuine curiosity, and let’s just say curiosity killed every cat within a nine-mile radius. Frontman Damonteal Harris describes the record as "an insane mixture of drop G and Drop F songs," which is a remarkably polite way of saying the low end feels like dropping a refrigerator down an … Read more

East End Redemption

...If You Want to Live!
Independent (2026)

Escape is not an option! This EP from Portland, Maine’s East End Redemption, fully delivers with the catchiest pop-punk hooks and roaring guitars that keep things driving along. Heavy on the sci-fi lyrics, I felt like I was hurling through the cosmos, fighting off space creatures and devils from Mars. Being a fan of the Lillingtons helps, though having some … Read more

Mid Rats

Enemies Within
Fail Harmonic Records (2026)

Sometimes you don't need a record to reinvent the wheel. Sometimes you just want something fast, loud, politically charged, and pissed off enough to make you want to start throwing yourself around the room. That's exactly what Pennsylvania's Mid Rats deliver with Enemies Within, an eight song, 25-minute blast of hardcore punk that wastes very little time getting down to … Read more