Review
The Black Hollies
Casting Shadows

Ernest Jenning (2008) Loren

The Black Hollies – Casting Shadows cover artwork
The Black Hollies – Casting Shadows — Ernest Jenning, 2008

The Black Hollies feature three-fifths of Jersey City's Rye Coalition, but don't expect Casting Shadows, the trippy-covered Ernest Jenning release to match Rye Coalition's dirty rock. The Black Hollies play a blend of psychedelic and 60's garage-pop, complete with flowery imagery, sweet harmonies, and fuzzy guitar interludes.

The album shifts between fuzzed out psychedelic and group harmony pop, with the stronger moments being those that hint toward garage rock. After a forgettable "Whispers Beneath the Willows" starts the record, a catchy bass/drum opening on "Paisley Pattern Ground" picks up the tempo and gets things rocking. Generally speaking, the album alternates between the two different styles, fuzzy and then poppy-rock, back to fuzzy. Unfortunately, the spacey songs lose my interest and nothing really sticks out until the harmonic "Hamilton Park Ballerina," which sounds like a Scooby-Doo chase song, but with subtle dirty rock'n'roll lying just underneath its saccharine melody. The same goes for "Bruised Tangerines," featuring organ and electric sitar, but I can't shake the '60s imagery, and based on the song's title the imagery is The Black Hollies' primary intention.

"That Little Girl," sounds straight out of the 60s, with pure sappy about-a-girl sweetness: "I need your love / Yes, indeed / I need your love / I'm beggin' pleas e/ I need your love / Day and nigh t/ I need your love / It's outta sight." The music matches the lyrics, and you can picture the object of affection "shaking it the way she does" for two-and-half minutes. It's followed by another poppy love piece, "If You Won't Let Go," with hooky guitars that somehow reminds me of "Hello, I Love You." While neither of these songs is particularly striking in the originality department, they capture The Black Hollies at their strongest: offering catchy 1960s pop, resplendent with period imagery. There's just enough pent-up energy in the rhythm section and I suspect the live act exceeds the record in expressing this.

The lyrical imagery and throwback art - from the acid-wash cover to the booklet layout with management contacts and a descriptive band paragraph on the back of the CD - the whole thing feels a little too manufactured as a revival piece instead of a forward-thinking album. While I appreciate the remembering-another-era-of-rock, let's not forget that these Jersey City residents aren't actually living in the 1960s. It's cute, but Casting Shadows brings nothing new to the table.

With a track listing as listed below, and lyrics proclaiming, "The colors and the shapes / Really move me to the sounds," it is safe to judge the book by the cover.

1. Whispers Beneath the Willows

2. Paisley Pattern Ground

3. Under a Winter's Spell

4. The Autumn Chateau

5. Hamilton Park Ballerina

6. Bruised Tangerines

7. That Little Girl

8. If You Won't Let Go

9. Running Through My Mind

10. Patient Sparrow

5.5 / 10Loren • April 13, 2008

The Black Hollies – Casting Shadows cover artwork
The Black Hollies – Casting Shadows — Ernest Jenning, 2008

Related news

The Black Hollies Post New Song

Posted in MP3s on May 29, 2009

Recently-posted album reviews

Middle-Aged Queers

Theatre of Shame
Engineer Records, Sell The Heart Records (2025)

Theatre Of Shame is the third LP from Bay Area band Middle-Aged Queers, a band whose moniker definitely gives away the plot. The band celebrates community with party punk songs like "Glizzies Banging" and "Pajama Party," but it also has pointed political commentary about the dangers of a bigoted society. In equal parts, Theatre Of Shame is about celebration and … Read more

Sleep Pod Two

Rehearse Your Future
Mindpower Records (2025)

You can always tell when a band contains seasoned musicians. They give off a different aura through their music and it sounds complete. It just meshes better. The songwriting is well done, the vocal melodies are catchy, and the transitions from verses, choruses, and bridges are complex but accessible. That is the case with this band. Let me introduce you … Read more

The World Is A Beautiful Place & I Am No Longer Afraid To Die

Dreams of Being Dust
Epitaph (2025)

I’m instantly drawn to bands that have intriguing or long names. Without even listening to the first note of the band, I know it’s going to be pushing the boundaries of normalcy in music. Which is why it should be no surprise that TWIABP, in certain spots through this album, remind me of the band ...And You Will Know Us … Read more