Review
This Moment
Finding a Voice in the Dark

Uprising (2005) Josh F.

This Moment – Finding a Voice in the Dark cover artwork
This Moment – Finding a Voice in the Dark — Uprising, 2005

Playing music in a genre like metalcore is a difficult thing. You've got to do what you do very well to separate yourself from the rest of the pack. Even then, odds are you will be tagged as such and thrown in with the rest of the pack of 18 Visions', Atreyu's, and Unearth's.

Finding a Voice in the Dark, the debut full length from Southern California's This Moment, is a record you will either love or hate. It all depends on your stance on this style of music, which seems to permeate more from California than from any other state in the union.

Many will take note of this band because of their producer; Former Death By Stereo bassist Paul Miner. Yep, the same guy who produced Atreyu's Suicide Notes and Butterfly Kisses. As you might expect from that, This Moment's sound could fit well on Victory Records' current roster of bands using interchanging vocals of singing and screaming as well as catchy guitar riffs with breakdown after breakdown. At times, This Moment comes off as the bastard child of The Bled, Shai Hulud, and Atreyu.

The band often uses lyrical imagery that has become far far too typical. The songs make use of imagery such as razor blades and blood, along with songs reeking of desperate heartbreak and loneliness. These songs are delivered with not so much of a higher pitched scream as it is with a guttural howl, making it less obvious how cheesy these songs are at times.

Despite all these things, Finding a Voice in the Dark could have been much worse of a debut than it is. The members of this band are still young, and surely have not yet decided where there sound will go from here. If this band can keep Paul Miner in their camp, as they mature they will have someone competent to guide them along the path to making some great records in their future.

6.0 / 10Josh F. • August 31, 2005

This Moment – Finding a Voice in the Dark cover artwork
This Moment – Finding a Voice in the Dark — Uprising, 2005

Recently-posted album reviews

Alien Nosejob

How A Mosquito Operates
Anti Fade, Iron Lung (2026)

The one-man band of Alien Nosejob continues to crank out short, angry hardcore in quick bursts. I've lost count of how many records Jake Robertson has now released under the name. I'll just say that while the first couple took some direction changes, the project seems to have found its footing in 1980s-influenced hardcore. With 17 songs in 24 minutes, … Read more

Cancer Bats

Give Me Dirt
Marshall Amplification PLC, New Damage records (2026)

ALBUM HIGHLIGHTS – “Bright Eyes of Gold”, “Give Me Dirt”, “Long Tooth”, “Fools Like You” Almost exactly two years ago, on 8th August 2024, Cancer Bats played Conne Island in Leipzig – a choice they would live to regret. Unbeknownst to them at the time, the centre had slowly become renowned for its radical politics and, more recently, the ban … Read more

Tyler Sonnichsen

The Dead Milkmen
J-Card Press (2026)

When I saw The Dead Milkmen at Toronto’s Diamond Club back in the late 1980s, the floor was a volatile, beautiful mess of colliding subcultures. It was like different species of house flies bumping into one another, wondering what the hell you were doing in the mason jar. You had suburban high school pocket-pen-protector pencil-neck nubile nerds, college radio snobs … Read more