Reviews Foo Fighters Concrete and Gold

Foo Fighters

Concrete and Gold

One thing becomes abundantly clear about 28 seconds into "T-Shirt", the first track off Foo Fighters' ninth studio album Concrete and Gold - this will not be your typical Foo Fighters album.

What's different about it? Well for starters, the way it was made. After recording 2011's Wasting Light in Grohl's house and garage, then writing and recording Sonic Highways in a different city to influence and represent each song, the band has done a 180 and recorded in a regular studio. With a regular producer. In the same city. Fucking weirdos.

Of course, it has since been revealed that original plans to make the album on stage at the Hollywood Bowl in front of a live audience were scrapped after PJ Harvey recorded in a similar fashion her latest effort The Hope Six Demolition Project, and thus beating the Foos to the punch of the record button.

One would argue that at this point in their career the band doesn't need to rely on a "gimmick" in order to sell records and they would be right. They don't. But it would seem that Dave Grohl is like a shark that just can't seem to stop swimming for fear of drowning, thus always looking for something to pique his interest.

So what piqued his interest this time? That would be producer Greg Kurstin, and his indie band The Bird and the Bee. Loving the lush vocal arrangements Kurstin provided on both his own band's albums as well as music he had produced for the likes of Adele, Sia and Pink, Grohl approached him to helm the band's new album.

First single "Run" was very much an expected listen, employing the loud-quiet-loud formula that the band has been using effectively since their 1995 debut. But looking beyond "Run", Concrete and Gold is probably the group's most experimental record and like all experiments, some are successful in their formula and execution, and some just aren't. 

Take "Sunday Rain", for example. On the surface, it's an inoffensive Beatles-esque mid-tempo number that doesn't initially catch the ear save for one glaring reason. It just doesn't sound like Foo Fighters. 

Whereas a track like T"he Sky Is A Neighborhood" - a sparsely arranged, also Beatles-esque track with a rousing singalong chorus, even with all these non-formulaic descriptives still manages to be unmistakably Foo Fighters.

Foo Fighters have always managed to be very aurally palatable while maintaining a slight edge to their sound that helped to foster them as a hard rocking group even as they navigated the charts usually reserved for the likes of Beyonce. But Kurstin's production neuters them in a sense and the individual abilities of Grohl, bassist Nate Mendel, Guitarists Pat Smear and Chris Shiflett, drummer Taylor Hawkins and newest full-time member Rami Jaffee get lost in the production.

There's no telling what direction Foo Fighters will take next, and to their credit they could have very easily played it safe with Concrete and Gold - delivering more of that dude-rock that folks have come to know and love and heaven knows you can't fault a band for not wanting to alienate their listeners. But there's something to be said for a band that, even if the listener can't connect to the music as easily, isn't afraid to challenge them every once in a while either.

7.0 / 10Kevin Fitzpatrick
Leave a comment

RCA

2017

7.0 / 10

7.0 / 10

Share this content
More by Foo Fighters

Foo Fighters

Sonic Highways

7.2 / 10 Foo Fighters - Sonic Highways album cover

With their newest release, Sonic Highways, we aptly find Foo Fighters at an apparent crossroads and no longer content to write and record music in a traditional fashion. Sonic Highways ...

Foo Fighters

Wasting Light

8.4 / 10 Foo Fighters - Wasting Light album cover

Dave Grohl is a man of the people. For the last 16 years he's been one of the most endearing figures in hard music. Terminally cool, brutally honest and adept ...

Foo Fighters

Echoes, Silence, Patience and Grace

8.3 / 10 Foo Fighters - Echoes, Silence, Patience and Grace album cover

In their twelve or so years as a band, Foo Fighters have had a more than respectable career. This is equally impressive as it would seem that no one ever ...

Related news

Records Sonic Highways headed for video

Posted March 12, 2015, 8:32 p.m.

Foo Fighters' HBO Series Sonic Highways is headed for DVD, Blu Ray, and digital release on April 7.The series follows the band and musical history across 8 US cities ...

Tours Foo Fighters announce 2015 tour

Posted Nov. 18, 2014, 4:59 p.m.

Planning in advance, Foo Fighters have booked a 2015 North American tour, including support from Royal Blood and Mission of Burma on select dates. The long-running band released Sonic Highways ...

Records Foo Fighters announce 8th album

Posted Sept. 19, 2014, 7:41 a.m.

The Foo Fighters will release their eighth full-length album, Sonic Highways, on Nov. 10. The record was recorded in several locations by the band and Butch Vig and will be ...

x

Logo

Looking for the SPB logo? You can download it in a range of styles and colours here:

Click anywhere outside this dialog to close it, or press escape.