Reviews Brendan Kelly & The Wandering Birds I'd Rather Die Than Live Forever

Brendan Kelly & The Wandering Birds

I'd Rather Die Than Live Forever

I’ve never thought of Brendan Kelly as much of a singer. Sure, I’ve followed his career—hell, Slapstick played at the first real DIY show I ever saw—but he’s always been in that category of “punk vocalist,” who relies on attitude far more than vocal chops. As such, I had pretty mixed feelings coming into his solo project Brendan Kelly & the Wandering Birds for their debut full-length I’d Rather Die than Live Forever.

Brendan Kelly & the Wandering Birds, though, is a different beast than his Wasted Potential material in 2010. There, he did the singer-songwriter thing with an acoustic guitar. The Wandering Birds is a full band, and they don’t waste time is introducing the concept. Opener “Suffer the Children, Come unto Me” is a rocker. Sure, it starts out with a minimal guitar line and Kelly’s voice, but it builds into a higher volume affair with a driving beat. It differs from his other projects in two primary ways. Musically the record covers a lot of ground. It’s rooted in punk rock, absolutely, but verse-chorus-verse power chords don’t dominate the songwriting in the same way. Second, the lyrics here, to put it pretty directly (because, hey, that’s what Kelly would do), are perverse and dark. I’d Rather Die than Forever isn’t about Kelly’s exploration on the meaning of life: it’s about crafting disturbing characters who walk the shadows and lurk in alleyways and behind bushes. Each song builds on ideas of obsession and derangement, exploring them through a character perspective instead of the ol’ punk rock sloganeering.

This blend in the content works rather well. The in-depth explorations of perversity give a more complicated base that forces the music to stretch out, and the energetic, forward-moving music gives the lyrics an added darkness that becomes somewhat obscured and blurry as it passes the listeners’ ears before it can truly set in. Sitting down with the lyric insert for this record is a vastly different experience than grabbing your iPod and catching a bus. A song like “Dance of the Doomed” has a bounce to its step, moving forward with a positive sound, while the lyrics tell a wholly different story. In that sense, perhaps it can be compared with “Unicorn Odyssey” from The Falcon’s album, covering a despicable character while the music keeps you moving. If Kelly had approached this content with, say, a creepy and plodding Tom Waits style, the record would be entirely off-putting. Instead, the vibe coming from the instrumentation complements his stories without doing a disservice to the tone.

Still, for all the talk of how this project is different, its primary audience will be fans of Kelly’s other bands over the last decade. It falls mostly in line with The Lawrence Arms and The Falcon, while mixing in a wider range of influences that expand the base without slowing down the pace or derailing the song structures. It sees a lot of new sounds seeping into the content, but Kelly’s songwriting is a familiar style and the new additions work well, even the world beat that works its way into “Your Mother.” It doesn’t break ground, and the creepy angle will alienate a few, but it’s a solid record with a few standouts (“Suffer the Children, Come unto Me” and “latenightsupersonicplasticbags”) and few faults. It may not have Neil Hennessy and Chris McCaughan playing together, but it will help fans waiting for the next Lawrence Arms. After Wasted Potential, it’s much better than I’d expected.

7.5 / 10Loren
Radio K 2
Leave a comment

7.5 / 10

7.5 / 10

Share this content
Related features

Music Red Scare 10th Anniversary Show Review

Posted Nov. 12, 2014, 3:24 p.m.

Most of you are still recovering from Fest, but let’s not forget that Red Scare had a little fest of their own for their ...

Radio K 2
Recent reviews


True Capacity

7.5 / 10 Astpai - True Capacity album cover

Austrian touring machine Astpai are ready to release their sixth full length album unto the world. Astpai has held a low profile recently. Their previous album Burden Calls is from 2014. Ok, ...

La Armada

Anti-Colonial Vol. 1

7.3 / 10 La Armada  - Anti-Colonial Vol. 1 album cover
200 Words Or Less

I usually lean more melodic than heavy in my daily listening. But there’s a time and place for everything, and La Armada definitely hit that craving for pure vitriolic aggression. ...

Alice In Chains

Rainier Fog

8.3 / 10 Alice In Chains - Rainier Fog album cover

It’s been 12 years since Alice In Chains reactivated with vocalist William DuVall - making his time in the band roughly twice that of Layne Staley, but the shadow left ...

Related news

Videos Brendan Kelly acoustic (The Falcon, Wandering Birds)

Posted July 6, 2016, 7:03 p.m.

Punks in Vegas is streaming video of a recent 3-song set from The Falcon's lead vocalist Brendan Kelly (also of The Lawrence Arms, and Brendan Kelly and the Wandering ...



Looking for the SPB logo? You can download it in a range of styles and colours here:

Click anywhere outside this dialog to close it, or press escape.