Feature / Interviews
New Idea Society

Words: Shane • Posted pre-2010

New Idea Society's full length is easily one of the most unique albums to be released in recent memory. Stephen Brodsky and Mike Law have composed original songs teeming with lo-fi rock, 60's pop, and hints of folk. So if you haven't bought into the hype yet, it's not too late to run out to your local record store for a copy.

Scene Point Blank: First off, I want to start off saying that I really enjoy the new album; it's one of my favorites of the year so far. Besides the fact that the two of you are in other bands, was there any other major hold-ups in putting this record out?

Stephen Brodsky: I'll let Mike take this one!

Mike Law: Thanks, Glad that you like the record. I am excited how much is happening around it and the response we are getting. Our schedules were really the main thing that slowed the record. At the time Cave In was pretty much touring the entire world. Eulcid was also touring a lot and doing stuff with the Boston DIY community. This left very little time for us to work on the record. By the time we finished it the original label seemed to be in a money crunch. We toyed with the idea of doing it with some bigger indies, but they were too shady, so we went with someone we could trust in Magic Bullet.

Scene Point Blank: Although the name itself is taken from a Giants Chair song, was the name meant to imply some sort of musical progressiveness, be it within your own realm of writing, or the whole music field?

Mike: I honestly cannot remember quite why we took that name. Not to much thought was put into it really (which I kind of regret now). We had a few offers to release some of our songs so when one went on a sampler we just went with that name. I suppose it is kind of nice though as The Giants Chair was one of the first bands Stephen and I bonded over.

Scene Point Blank: You have quite a few former and current projects and all of them seem to touch on very different styles. When did you start toying around with the idea of New Idea Society? What were you listening to at the time and what bands/artists have influenced you to keep on with it?

Mike: Eulcid was something that consumed me conceptually and politically. NIS is something that would just happen. I would pick up a guitar and a song would already be there. I have always written songs of this type so it is natural something like this album would eventually see the light of day. I do not foresee a time when I will not write songs like this. They just happen. I only have to pay attention to how I am feeling. As far as the what I was listening to influencing the songs, I don't think that is particularly relevant. I think what I was listening to may have influenced the sounds more than the songs. I remember specifically thinking about The Beach Boys' "Smile" when we recorded the vocal harmonies for "Waiting For the Moment To Oblige", and George Harrison on some of the guitar solos. I like the sounds of those recordings. More than anything though I simply enjoy Stephen and I sitting around thinking about how we want to interpret the song.

Stephen: Between the two of us is where the inspiration could be rooted. I really enjoy Mike's songwriting, and his tunes have helped me develop an appreciation for songwriters like Robert Smith, Frank Black, and Woody Guthrie... he'd always come around to referencing those people's work when it came time to actually collaborate on New Idea Society tunes.

Scene Point Blank: I noticed that some of the vocal melodies on this record are very reminiscent to the ones found on Cave In's, Tides of Tomorrow. Were you in the process of writing this record at the same time as that or was that something that all of Cave In wanted to explore as well?

Mike: I haven't noticed that. It is possible.

Stephen: A bulk of the NIS album was in the works at around the same time "Tides Of Tomorrow" was being mapped out... I seem to remember Adam being on a big Beach Boys kick at the time, and very often a bootleg of "Smile" was played on Cave In trips.

Scene Point Blank: There seems to be a whole lot going on during this record. I recently heard you have Santos of Old Man Gloom/Forensics playing drums for the tour. Any plans on having other musicians sit in with you as well?

Mike: That very well may happen. These songs will be interpreted in many different ways over the next few tours. I want in no way to define these songs or lock them to any particular version.

Related features

The Seize

One Question Interviews • December 31, 2025

Cesar Ruiz (The Seize - vocals) SPB: How do you typically choose your album art? Ruiz: Album art has started with lyrics. When I’m writing, I’ll have these images in mind that represent the feelings or themes within the songs. Those ideas usually become the starting point for the cover. … Read more

Chairmaker

One Question Interviews • December 30, 2025

Neil Erskine (Chairmaker) SPB: If Chairmaker had a physical form like a place, a thing, or a smell, what would it be? Erskine: There is a very specific chair - but you've got to read Banks' Use of Weapons. No spoilers.   Read more

Ugly Stick

One Question Interviews • December 29, 2025

Ugly Stick SPB: Describe in your own words the “Columbus Sound” and what it means or has meant to you and your musical output. David Holm (vocals and guitars): As it pertains to Ugly Stick I would say it's kind of an amalgam of punk rock, country, and classic rock. … Read more

Scene Point Blank's Favorites: Year End (2025)

Music / Year End 2025 • December 23, 2025

Every year we diligently assemble a list of our favorite albums of the year. Each SPB staff member enters the large arena we nickname THE DOJO, and yells out the name of their top album of the year. Rival staffers quickly assemble and shout out their own highly-favored record, and … Read more

Pass The Mic: Artists and labels on 2025

Music / Year End 2025 • December 23, 2025

For many years now, Scene Point Blank has taken the opportunity as the year ends to formally "pass the mic" to our friends on the other side of the mostly-imaginary divide between listeners and artists. This year is no exception as we ask a bunch of bands, artists and labels … Read more

Related news

What's up with New Idea Society

Posted in Bands on February 23, 2019

New Idea Society Post New Songs

Posted in MP3s on December 10, 2009

New Idea Society To Enter Studio

Posted in Records on February 20, 2008

Related reviews

New Idea Society

The World is Bright and Lonely
Exotic Fever (2007)

For The World is Bright and Lonely, New Idea Society's Mike Law walks a fine line between poetry and prose. The lyrical structures are simple and for the most part unchanging, and there is a more simple pattern within it all, almost every line the start of a new thought or idea. But herein lies the genius and creativity that … Read more

New Idea Society

You Are Awake Or Asleep
Magic Bullet (2005)

Cave In has been on hiatus for a couple months now and Stephen Brodsky has decided to not sit still. Rumor has it he is working on a new solo album, there is a video being worked on for his solo stuff, and he finally got around to putting out a New Idea Society full length, a follow-up to their … Read more

More from this section

Pulley and Fire Sale - Double interview

Interviews • December 6, 2025

When two bands come together on a split release, it’s more than just sharing music on vinyl. It’s a conversation in sound. Pulley and Fire Sale recently teamed up for a split 7" through Negative Progression Records that showcases both of their unique voices while still feeling like a cohesive … Read more

The Saints

Interviews • November 14, 2025

As The Skids sang, The Saints are coming!.......Storming North America! The Saints ’73-’78 land on North American soil in early November and will feature original Saints members, guitarist Ed Kuepper and drummer Ivor Hay, and filling out this lineup is singer Mark Arm (Mudhoney), guitarist Mick Harvey (The Birthday Party … Read more

Fest 23: Artist Interviews

Interviews / Fest 23 • October 18, 2025

FEST 23 takes place later this month, from Oct. 24-26 in Gainesville, FL. Something like a billion bands are driving, flying, canoeing, and snowshoeing to the festival from across the country -- many of them for the first time and many come back to play nearly every year. Scene Point … Read more